A savings financing company operating under Law No. 6361 asked whether it can rediscount under TPL 281 and 285 the instalments of organisation fees falling into the next calendar year, balances transferred to the savings pool and tracked in account 300, and balances tracked in account 124 after allocation.
The Administration's view:
- For Law No. 6802 the company is a banker and a Banking and Insurance Transactions Tax (BITT) taxpayer; its organisation fee income is subject to BITT.
- For banks, bankers and insurance companies, rediscounting receivables and payables not yet due, whether or not supported by notes, is not optional.
- Organisation fee receivables falling into later calendar years must be rediscounted at period ends under TPL 281.
- Balances transferred to the savings pool and balances whose maturities continue after allocation are not receivables/payables of the kind subject to rediscounting and cannot be rediscounted.
The ruling is relevant to savings financing companies.
Full text
Subject: Rediscounting at a savings financing company
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.
From examination of your ruling request form referred to above and its annex, it is understood that, stating that you are a financial institution operating under Financial Leasing, Factoring, Financing and Savings Financing Companies Law No. 6361, that through the savings financing system forming your field of activity some of your customers save while others obtain financing, and that in this context you organise these transactions and manage the fund accumulated in the savings pool, you request our Directorate's opinion on whether you can apply rediscounting under Articles 281 and 285 of Tax Procedure Law No. 213:
- to instalment amounts falling into the next calendar year where the organisation fee to be paid to your company by customers entering the system is paid in instalments,
- to balances taken from customers during the savings period, transferred to the fund pool and tracked in account "300- Short-Term Payables to the Savings Fund Pool",
- to balances whose maturities appear after allocation and which are tracked in account "124- Savings Financing Receivables".
I- Expenditure Taxes Law No. 6802 Aspect
The second and third paragraphs of Article 28 of Expenditure Taxes Law No. 6802 provide:
"Money received in cash or on account in their favour under any name by bankers due to banking transactions and services they perform (including money remaining in favour of those who have made it their profession to buy and sell securities for their own or others' account, to intermediate in buying and selling, or to undertake to pay debts against securities they buy and sell, due to these activities, and money received under names such as commission, fee or service charge on income and benefits provided on money collected by those continuously engaged in collecting money to pay deposit interest or provide interest and similar benefits under other names) is also subject to banking transactions tax.
Those engaged in lending under Decree-Law No. 90 and those carrying out any of the transactions and services specified in the second paragraph as their main field of activity are deemed bankers in the application of this Law..."
Article 30 of the same Law, which determines the taxpayer, provides that banking and insurance transactions tax (BITT) is paid by banks, bankers and insurance companies.
The section B/2-, titled "Those Carrying Out the Transactions and Services Specified in the Second Paragraph of Article 28 of Law No. 6802 as Their Main Field of Activity", of Expenditure Taxes General Communiqué Serial No. 87 states: "... Those carrying out the transactions specified in the second paragraph of Article 28 of Law No. 6802 as their main field of activity means persons carrying out these transactions by being authorised or permitted under the relevant laws. Therefore, their transactions specified in the second paragraph of Article 28 of Law No. 6802 will be subject to BITT as their "main field of activity", while the same transactions of others will be subject to VAT since they are not their "main field of activity"."
On the other hand, subparagraph (j) of the first paragraph of Article 3 of Financial Leasing, Factoring, Financing and Savings Financing Companies Law No. 6361 defines organisation fee as "the amount customers will pay in return for savings financing activity and management of the savings fund pool under the savings financing agreement", and subparagraph (l) defines savings financing activity as "saving for a certain period on interest-free financing principles for the acquisition of a dwelling, roofed workplace or vehicle, provided predetermined conditions under an agreement are met, extending financing to customers and managing the savings collected".
Within the framework of the provisions and explanations above, your company is a BITT taxpayer within the banker scope for the application of Law No. 6802, and the organisation fee income you obtain from the savings financing activity you carry out with the operating permit obtained from the Banking Regulation and Supervision Board under Law No. 6361 is subject to BITT.
II- Tax Procedure Law No. 213 Aspect
Tax Procedure Law No. 213 provides:
- in Article 3: "A) Application of tax laws: ... Tax laws have effect by their wording and spirit. Where the wording is not clear, the provisions of tax laws are applied taking into account their purpose, the place of the provisions in the structure of the law and their connection with other articles. B) Proof: In taxation, the real nature of the taxable event and the transactions relating to it is essential. ...",
- in Article 258: "Valuation is the assessment and determination of economic assets relating to the calculation of tax bases.",
- in Article 259: "In valuation, the values that economic assets have on the days and times shown in tax laws are taken as the basis.",
- in Article 264: "Savings value is the real value an economic asset has for its owner on the valuation day.",
- in Article 265: "Recorded value is the account value of an economic asset shown in the accounting records.",
- in Article 281:
"Receivables are valued at their recorded values. Receivables based on deposit or loan agreements are taken into account together with interest to be calculated until the valuation day.
Receivables supported by notes that are not yet due may be reduced to their valuation day value. In that case, if the interest rate is stated in the note this rate, and if not, the official discount rate of the Central Bank of the Republic is applied.
Banks, bankers and insurance companies reduce their receivables to their valuation day value either at the official discount rate of the Central Bank of the Republic or at the interest rate they apply in their transactions.",
- in Article 285:
"Payables are valued at their recorded values. Payables based on deposit or loan agreements are taken into account together with interest to be calculated until the valuation day.
Payables supported by notes that are not yet due may be reduced to their valuation day value. In that case, if the interest rate is stated in the note this rate, and if not, interest at the official discount rate of the Central Bank of the Republic is applied.
Banks, bankers and insurance companies reduce their payables to their valuation day value at the official discount rate of the Central Bank of the Republic or the interest rate they apply in their transactions.
Taxpayers who reduce their receivable notes to valuation day value are obliged to treat their payable notes in the same way."
In addition, explanations on rediscounting under Articles 281 and 285 of that Law are given in Tax Procedure Law General Communiqués Serial Nos. 173, 238 and 369 and Tax Procedure Law Circulars Nos. 41 and 64.
In this context, under the provisions of that Law, although receivables and payables are essentially valued at recorded value on valuation days, receivables and payables not yet due may be reduced by taxpayers to their valuation day value. For reduction to valuation day value, those receivables and payables must be supported by notes for taxpayers other than banks, bankers and insurance companies, whereas banks, bankers and insurance companies also reduce receivables and payables not supported by notes to their valuation day value.
Also, although reducing receivables and payables not yet due to valuation day value (rediscounting) is not mandatory for taxpayers other than bankers and insurance companies, taxpayers who reduce their receivable notes not yet due to valuation day value are obliged to treat their payable notes not yet due in the same way. For banks, bankers and insurance companies, reducing their receivables and payables not yet due to valuation day value (rediscounting), whether or not supported by notes, is not optional.
In addition, in the application of Income Tax Law No. 193, the accrual basis applies to earning commercial income. In determining period income, it is essential that income and expenses are accounted for on the accrual basis and that revenue, income and profits are matched with costs, expenses and losses of the same period relating to earning and maintaining commercial income.
In this framework, a receivable/payable to be rediscounted must essentially relate to earning and maintaining the taxpayer's commercial income, be a receivable/payable not yet due (with maturity falling in the next period/periods), have been recorded as revenue-income-profit/cost-expense-loss, and have the nature of a real receivable/payable.
On the other hand, Financial Leasing, Factoring, Financing and Savings Financing Companies Law No. 6361, published in Official Gazette No. 28496 of 13/12/2012, provides:
- in Article 3:
"(1) In the application of this Law;
...
j) Organisation fee: means the amount customers will pay in return for savings financing activity and management of the savings fund pool under the savings financing agreement,
k) Allocation: means the payment on account, under the savings financing agreement and provided the conditions for entitlement to allocation are met, of the customer's accumulated savings and the financing amount committed under the agreement to third parties acting as sellers, for the customer, their heir or proxy to acquire a dwelling, roofed workplace or vehicle,
l) Savings financing activity: means saving for a certain period on interest-free financing principles for the acquisition of a dwelling, roofed workplace or vehicle, provided predetermined conditions under an agreement are met, extending financing to customers and managing the savings collected,
m) Savings fund pool: means the amount remaining after deducting amounts given as allocations and savings repayments from the total of accumulated savings and financing repayments with the savings financing company in a certain period.",
- in Article 39/A:
"(1) A savings financing agreement is an agreement drawn up on interest-free financing principles that, depending on a certain savings amount and period and provided predetermined conditions are met, gives the customer the right to use financing for the acquisition of a dwelling, roofed workplace or vehicle, and gives the company the obligation to manage, repay and extend financing on the customer's accumulated savings amount and the right to receive an organisation fee.
...
(3) The customer has the right to withdraw from the savings financing agreement within fourteen days after its signing without giving any reason and without paying a penalty. If the customer uses this right of withdrawal, the company is obliged to refund the whole amount received from the customer, including the organisation fee, within fourteen days of notification of the withdrawal decision.
(4) The customer has the right to terminate the savings financing agreement until the end of the savings period. If the customer exercises the right of termination, the company is obliged to refund to the customer the total accumulated amount other than the organisation fee within the period to be determined by the Board. ...",
- in Article 39/B:
"...
(2) Savings financing companies must separate savings fund pool accounts from their other accounts. Savings fund pool assets cannot be used for any purpose other than fulfilling the companies' obligations arising from savings financing agreements, cannot be subject to a right of retention, assignment of receivables or set-off, cannot be pledged or shown as collateral, cannot be seized, including for the collection of public receivables, except for customers' receivables arising from savings financing agreements, and cannot be subject to interim injunction or precautionary attachment or included in a bankruptcy estate.
..."
In addition, the Regulation on the Establishment and Operating Principles of Savings Financing Companies, published in Official Gazette No. 31447 of 7/4/2021, provides:
- in Article 17:
"(1) Where the agreement ends before allocation, customers' rights to take back their savings with the company cannot be limited in any way, subject to the repayment periods determined under the eighth paragraph.
...
(7) For the savings period, no collateral such as mortgage, pledge or notes may be taken from the customer under the agreement, and no transaction may be made that would place the customer under a payment obligation other than the organisation fee.
(8) Where the customer uses the right of withdrawal from the agreement in the third paragraph of Article 39/A of the Law, all payments made, including the organisation fee, are refunded to the customer without any deduction within fourteen days of notification of the withdrawal decision to the company. ...",
- in Article 23:
"...
(5) The accounts in which amounts accumulated in the savings fund pool are held are separated from the company's own accounts. These accounts cannot be used other than for repayments to customers who end their agreements before the financing period or use the right of withdrawal, allocation payments and investment activities within this article."
Accordingly, since you are a BITT taxpayer within the banker scope for the application of Law No. 6802, you must rediscount at period ends under Article 281 of Law No. 213, whether or not supported by notes, the balances of your organisation fee receivables falling into later calendar years obtained within the savings financing activity you carry out with the operating permit obtained from the Banking Regulation and Supervision Board under Law No. 6361.
However, since the balances taken from customers and transferred to the fund pool under the savings financing agreement stated in your ruling application, and the balances whose maturities continue after allocation, are not receivables/payables of the nature specified above, it is not possible to rediscount them at period ends.
For your information.
(*) This ruling has been issued under Article 413 of Tax Procedure Law No. 213.
(**) This ruling is invalid if incorrect information has been provided on this matter while it is under tax examination, judicial review or settlement.
(***) If you act in accordance with this ruling issued at your request and tax has to be assessed as a result, no tax penalty will be imposed on you and no late payment interest will be calculated on the tax assessed.
Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.