TREN
Contact us

When a Housing Savings-Finance Contract Is Converted to Vehicle Financing, BSMV Is Calculated Only on the Additional Organisation Fee

OtherWhen a Housing Savings-Finance Contract Is Converted to Vehicle Financing, BSMV Is Calculated Only on the Additional Organisation FeePrivate ruling · 21 May 2025
Rast note

A savings finance company that calculates BSMV on amounts collected from customers who already own a registered dwelling asked whether BSMV arises again when, because some customers wish to buy a vehicle instead of a dwelling, these amounts are converted to vehicle financing without being refunded.

The Administration noted that in BSMV the taxable event occurs when a transaction is carried out and money remains in the taxpayer's favour as a result, and that under the legislation the financing subject can be changed once and no additional payment can be requested unless the contract amount is increased. When a housing contract is converted to a vehicle contract, BSMV is calculated only on any additional organisation fee arising, as of the date of the change.

The ruling is relevant to savings finance companies.

ShareLinkedInWhatsAppEmail

Full text

Subject: Whether BSMV arises again when amounts previously collected from customers are converted to vehicle financing without being refunded
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.

TO … SAVINGS FINANCE JOINT STOCK COMPANY

Reference: Your ruling request form dated … with document registration number ….

In the ruling request form referred to above, stating that your company, engaged in savings finance activity under Law No. 6361, calculates and accrues banking and insurance transactions tax (BSMV) on amounts collected in your favour from customers who have a dwelling registered in their name, but that some of your customers later requested to buy a vehicle instead of a dwelling and the amounts previously collected from these customers were thus converted to vehicle financing without being refunded to them, an opinion is requested on whether BSMV liability arises again for these amounts converted to vehicle financing.

The second and third paragraphs of Article 28 of Expenditure Taxes Law No. 6802 provide:

"Money received in cash or on account in their favour under whatever name by bankers because of banking transactions and services they carry out (including money remaining in their favour because of these activities for those who have made it their profession to buy and sell securities for their own or others' account, to intermediate in purchases and sales or to undertake to pay debts against securities they buy and sell, and money received under names such as commission, fee or service charge on income and benefits provided on money collected by those continuously engaged in collecting money to pay deposit interest or provide interest and similar benefits under other names) is also subject to banking transactions tax.
Those engaged in lending under Decree-Law No. 90 and those carrying out any of the transactions and services in the second paragraph as their main activity are deemed bankers in the application of this Law. ..."

Article 30 of the same Law, determining the taxpayer, provides that BSMV is paid by banks, bankers and insurance companies, and Article 31 on the base provides that the BSMV base is the amount of money written in Article 28.

Sub-paragraph (y) of the first paragraph of Article 29 of that Law was amended by sub-paragraph (c) of Article 6 of Law No. 7491 on Amending Certain Laws and Decree-Laws to read: "All transactions carried out by mortgage finance institutions and housing finance funds within housing finance as defined in the first paragraph of Article 57 of Law No. 6362, and money received in their favour because of housing loans extended by housing finance institutions under the same Law to consumers who, as of the date the loan is used, own no dwelling registered in their name, and refinancing of these loans.", and this amendment entered into force on 28/12/2023. Under this amendment, money received in their favour because of housing loans used directly by those who own a dwelling registered in their name as of the date the loan is used has been taken out of the exemption, thereby limiting the exemption for housing loans.

Furthermore, the first paragraph of Article 57 of Capital Markets Law No. 6362 provides: "Housing finance is extending loans to consumers for acquiring dwellings, leasing dwellings to consumers by financial leasing, extending loans to consumers secured by dwellings they own, and extending loans to refinance these loans. Transactions of housing finance institutions, housing finance funds and mortgage finance institutions based on or secured by these loans and receivables are also within this scope."

On the other hand, sub-paragraph (j) of the first paragraph of Article 3 of Law No. 6361 provides: "Organisation fee: means the amount customers will pay under the savings finance contract in return for the savings finance activity and the management of the savings fund pool..."; the first paragraph of Article 39/A provides: "A savings finance contract is a contract drawn up according to interest-free financing principles that gives the customer the right to use financing for acquiring a dwelling, roofed workplace or vehicle, subject to the fulfilment of predetermined conditions depending on a specific savings amount and period, and gives the company the obligation to manage, repay and extend financing on the customer's accumulated savings and the right to receive an organisation fee."; and the fifth paragraph provides: "Savings finance contracts contain at least provisions on amounts, maturity, organisation fee, income, costs and expenses, periods and conditions for saving and extending financing for acquiring a dwelling, roofed workplace or vehicle, refund periods and conditions, default, use of the right of withdrawal, termination and rescission of the contract, transfer to heirs and to third parties, and the rights and obligations of the parties. Companies must fulfil the obligations they undertake under savings finance contracts. The procedures and principles for informing the customer under the contract and for the application of this article are determined by the Board."

Furthermore, the fourth paragraph of Article 16 of the Regulation on the Establishment and Operating Principles of Savings Finance Companies sets out the minimum elements to be included in savings finance contracts, listing among them provisions on the contract amount, organisation fee and financing subject, and the tenth paragraph of Article 17 of the same Regulation states: "The customer may change the financing subject consisting of a dwelling, roofed workplace or vehicle once, by a request submitted in writing or remotely by means of distance communication, until the end of the savings period of the savings finance contract. This request is fulfilled by companies within fifteen business days at the latest. In changes of financing subject, if the customer also requests a change in the contract amount, no additional payment may be requested other than the organisation fee corresponding to the difference arising from the increase in the contract amount and any additional taxes arising."

Letter No. 134878 dated 26/11/2024 received following correspondence with the Banking Regulation and Supervision Agency on the subject states:

"The fifth paragraph of Article 39/A of Law No. 6361, headed 'Savings finance contract', and the fourth paragraph of Article 16 of the Regulation, headed 'Savings finance contract', list among the minimum elements to be included in savings finance contracts provisions on the contract amount, organisation fee and financing subject, and it is considered that the contract concluded as a result of changes planned to these provisions at the customer's request is in the nature of a new contract different from the first contract. However, looking at common practice across the sector, it is also known that customers' requests for changes in the type of financing are met by companies by creating a new contract or a supplementary contract to the previous contract. ... In this framework, although savings finance companies consider the change of financing subject to be in the nature of a new contract, it is considered that money remaining in their favour/income arising as a result of that transaction is possible only if the contract amount also increases."

In this framework, under the legislation in force on savings finance companies, the financing subject consisting of a dwelling, roofed workplace or vehicle can be changed once by the customer until the end of the savings period of the savings finance contract, and if the customer also requests a change in the contract amount, no additional payment can be requested other than the organisation fee corresponding to the difference arising from the increase in the contract amount and any additional taxes arising.

Furthermore, as also stated in Expenditure Taxes General Communiqué Serial No. 89, for the taxable event to occur in BSMV, the conditions of a transaction being carried out and money remaining in the taxpayer's favour as a result of that transaction must be met together. Therefore, in BSMV each transaction is considered independently on its own, and the money received in the taxpayer's favour as a result of that transaction is taxed. In other words, if no income is earned (no money remains in the taxpayer's favour) as a result of a transaction, there is no base subject to BSMV.

Accordingly, where the savings finance contract for acquiring a dwelling of a saver who has a dwelling registered in his name is changed once, at the saver's request, into a savings finance contract for acquiring a vehicle, if an additional organisation fee arises, BSMV must be calculated on this organisation fee as of the date the contract was changed.

For your information.

Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.