A cooperative in liquidation stated that the balance to be distributed to members on closing consists of dues remaining after expenses, prior-year profits on which corporate tax was paid (part declared with reservation and refunded by court decision), and bank interest subject to withholding in exempt periods, and asked which of these are subject to corporate tax or income tax withholding.
The Administration's view:
- If there are no non-member transactions after the start of liquidation, the exemption continues; dues collected and interest income subject to withholding are not subject to corporate tax.
- The land sale gain held not taxable by court decisions, whose assessment was cancelled, is not included in revenue in the final liquidation return.
- If there are non-member transactions after the start of liquidation, liability is established as a separate economic enterprise and those gains are subject to corporate tax.
- On distribution to members of prior-year profits on which corporate tax was paid and interest income subject to withholding, 15% withholding applies under ITL 94/6-b-i.
- No withholding applies where dues paid by members are refunded as they are; if income linked to dues such as interest or late payment charges is distributed, 15% withholding applies.
The ruling is relevant to cooperatives in liquidation.
Full text
Subject: Taxation of a cooperative distributing dues and profits to members on liquidation
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.
From examination of your ruling request form referred to above, stating that balance amounts will be distributed to members to complete the closing of your cooperative in liquidation, and that this balance consists of:
- amounts remaining after expenses from dues paid by members since the cooperative's establishment,
- prior-year profits on which corporate tax was paid on amounts declared as corporate income in periods when the cooperative was subject to corporate tax (prior-year profits also include corporate tax amounts declared with reservation and recovered by court decision),
- bank interest income all of which was subject to withholding in periods when the cooperative had a corporate tax exemption and therefore did not file a corporate tax return,
it is understood that our Directorate's opinion is requested on which of these amounts will be subject to corporate tax and/or income tax withholding when filing the liquidation return, and which will be left outside tax.
The second paragraph of Article 2 of Corporate Tax Law No. 5520 counts cooperatives among corporate taxpayers, and subparagraph (k) of the first paragraph of Article 4 of the Law provides that, excluding consumer and transport cooperatives, cooperatives whose articles of association contain provisions that profit is not distributed on capital, no share of profit is given to the chair and members of the board of directors, reserves are not distributed to members and business is done only with members, and which actually comply with these provisions, are exempt from corporate tax (Transactions of cooperatives with persons other than their members and transactions with their members on matters not in the cooperative's articles of association are "non-member" transactions. Disposal by cooperatives of fixtures, machinery, equipment, vehicles and similar depreciable economic assets allocated to the conduct of the activity and that have completed their economic life, and building cooperatives obtaining one workplace or dwelling per share by giving their own land in exchange for units, are not deemed non-member transactions. Due to non-member transactions of cooperatives, a separate economic enterprise attached to the cooperative's legal entity is deemed to have been formed. Cooperatives earning income from their economic enterprises and from participation in the capital of another fully taxable entity, and the later distribution of this income to members, do not affect the exemption. The procedures and principles for taxing income from non-member transactions are determined by the Ministry of Finance.).
The section titled "4.13.1. Exemption conditions" of Corporate Tax General Communiqué Serial No. 1 explains in detail the exemption conditions cooperatives must meet to benefit from the corporate tax exemption, and the following sections illustrate non-member transactions in detail by cooperative type; the Communiqué states:
- in the section titled "4.13.1.4. Doing business only with members":
"Since cooperatives aim to provide and protect certain economic interests of their members, and especially their needs relating to their profession and livelihood, the activity should normally be limited to members only. Therefore, for a cooperative to benefit from the corporate tax exemption, its articles of association must contain a provision on doing business only with members, and this provision must actually be complied with.
Non-member transactions cover not only transactions with non-members but also transactions with members on matters not in the cooperative's articles of association."
- in the section titled "14.5. Filing where cooperative income consists only of real estate rental income and deposit interest":
"Since cooperatives renting out their real estate is treated as a non-member transaction, corporate tax liability must be established for the economic enterprise deemed to have been formed attached to the cooperative's legal entity. However, where these economic enterprises have no other income-generating activity and their income consists only of real estate rental income subject to withholding and deposit interest subject to withholding, there is no need for them to file corporate tax returns (including provisional tax returns). The withholdings made will be final taxation.
Economic enterprises attached to the cooperative's legal entity that also have income from other non-member transactions in addition to real estate rental income and deposit interest subject to withholding must file a corporate tax return, and will include the real estate rental income and deposit interest in this return. However, the taxes paid by withholding on the rental income and deposit interest under Article 15 of the Corporate Tax Law will be offset against the corporate tax calculated.
..."
On the other hand, the first paragraph of Article 75 of Income Tax Law No. 193 defines income from movable capital, and item (2) of the second paragraph states that income from participation shares (profit shares of limited company partners, business partnerships and limited partners, and income distributed by cooperatives are included in this group. Distribution to members of profits from cooperatives' transactions with their members in proportion to their transactions with the cooperative is not deemed profit distribution.) is income from movable capital.
Article 94, titled "Tax Withholding", of that Law provides that the persons, institutions and organisations listed in the article are obliged to withhold against the income tax of beneficiaries when making the payments listed in the items of those articles (including those paid as advances) in cash or on account, and item (6/b-i) of that article provides that 15% withholding will be made on profit shares listed in items (1), (2) and (3) of the second paragraph of Article 75 distributed by fully taxable entities to fully taxable individuals, to those who are not income or corporate taxpayers and to those exempt from income tax (adding profit to capital is not deemed profit distribution).
On the other hand, liquidation is the process of transactions ensuring, for the dissolution and termination of entities, the determination and establishment of the entity's assets, receivables and payables, the collection of its receivables, the conversion of its assets into cash and payment of its debts, and the distribution of the remaining cash to the members under the law and articles of association.
The liquidation process ends with the cessation of procurement transactions related to the entity's operating process, as well as the disposal of merchandise stocks or other current and fixed assets in the business or their withdrawal from the business by its owners, and, for taxpayers with legal personality, also the deletion of their trade names from the trade registry.
However, on examination of the annex to your ruling request form and GİBİntranet records, it is understood that, asserting that the sale of the land held by you, made because there was no longer any possibility of realising the founding purpose as a result of zoning applications and as a requirement of the liquidation process, did not constitute a breach of the corporate tax exemption conditions, the refund of corporate tax declared with reservation for the …, … and … accounting periods was made the subject of lawsuits before the …, … and … Tax Courts; that all of those courts decided in the direction of "…" and ruled …; that appeals against these decisions before … Court were rejected; and that the decisions of that … Court were upheld before ….
According to these provisions and explanations, for your Cooperative, which entered liquidation as of …:
- if you have no non-member transactions after the liquidation start date, since your exemption will continue, the dues collected from your members and the bank interest income subject to withholding must not be subject to corporate tax,
- under the Court decisions given on the disputed transaction declared with reservation and litigated, since the land sale was not treated as a non-member transaction and the gain obtained was not treated as taxable income and the corporate tax assessment was cancelled, that gain recorded in the prior years' profits account must not be included in your revenue in the final liquidation return,
- if you have non-member transactions after the liquidation start date, liability must be established as a separate economic enterprise attached to the cooperative's legal entity, and your gains from non-member transactions must be subject to corporate tax,
- where prior years' profits on which corporate tax was paid as declared corporate income, and bank interest income all of which was subject to withholding, in the final balance sheet to be drawn up at the end of liquidation, are distributed to members, 15% income tax withholding must be made under item (6-b-i) of the first paragraph of Article 94 of the Income Tax Law,
- where dues collected from members are repaid to your members, no income tax withholding must be made if the dues paid by each member are refunded as they are, but where income linked to the dues collected such as interest, late payment charges, etc. is distributed to members, 15% income tax withholding must be made under item (6-b-i) of the first paragraph of Article 94 of the Income Tax Law.
For your information.
Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.