A technology development zone management company agreed that a bank would assign to it, for less than the receivable amount, the bank's uncollectable receivable and related collateral, following mortgage and enforcement disputes arising from the unpaid loan of its business partner that had borrowed for office construction. The company asked whether income arises from the assignment and whether it can use the fee exemption in Law No. 4691 in lawsuits or enforcement proceedings for these receivables.
The Administration's view:
- In this case, where the receivable is considered uncollectable and the debtor's tax registration has been closed ex officio, no accrued income arises; the difference between the assigned amount and the price paid is not taken as income in corporate income.
- If collections in later periods exceed the assignment price, the excess is included in corporate income in the relevant periods.
- Since lawsuits and enforcement proceedings for the assigned receivables are not transactions relating to the application of Law No. 4691, the management company cannot use the fee exemption in Article 8 for them.
The ruling is relevant to technology development zone management companies and entities acquiring distressed receivables at a discount.
Full text
Subject: Taxation of an assigned receivable
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.
From the ruling request form referred to above and its annexes, it is stated that:
- your Company was established under Technology Development Zones Law No. 4691 as the management company responsible for managing and operating the … zone, that an Easement Agreement for 30 years was signed between … and your Company on … for the construction of buildings to be located in this zone, and that a surface right for 49 years was established in your Company's name by the … administration on … on the property where the planned office constructions would be built,
- a tender was held for the planned office constructions and, as a result, a Cooperation Protocol dated … was signed with …,
- … used a loan to finance the constructions and signed an assignment agreement with the bank on … for repayment of these loan debts,
- under this agreement, … assigned to the bank, against its loan debts, the portion up to USD … of its principal and ancillary receivables arising and to arise under the Cooperation Protocol it had signed with your Company, and this assignment was accepted by your Company on the same date,
- on the basis of the Cooperation Protocol, a … was also signed on … between … and your Company providing for the sharing for … years of the rental income from the properties whose construction would be completed, the content of this agreement providing for the rental income to be collected in an account to be opened in your Company's name at … and, limited to the share of …, for sharing to take place after the loan amount drawn is closed; on this basis your Company established a mortgage in favour of … as collateral for …'s loan debts, and your Company owes USD … arising from the agreement,
- when … did not pay its loan debts, the bank started proceedings against your Company and … by way of realising the mortgage, those proceedings became final and a sale request was made,
- … filed a lawsuit against your Company and … for cancellation of the mortgage, the Court ordered as an interim measure that sale transactions and payments from the rental income collected in the joint account be stopped, and by decision dated … ruled that the mortgage registration be cancelled,
- in the case currently under appeal review, due to the interim measure ordered by the court, the transfer to … of the money deposited as rent can only be possible if … withdraws its request for the interim measure,
- as a result of these legal disputes, a … was signed between … and your Company providing that …, in order to close your debt to that company by becoming creditor again against your debt of … arising from …, will assign to you approximately … of its receivable and the related collateral for a price of …,
- your Company will pay approximately … of this price by the release of the rent assignment amounts accumulated in the enforcement file due to the interim measure,
and it is understood that our opinion is requested on:
- whether, for tax purposes, income arises for your Company from acquiring by assignment, for a price of …, the receivable of approximately …, which has become due but which … could not collect and which also cannot be collected by you,
- if income is deemed to arise, what its amount would be, and whether these receivables can be treated under the provisions on worthless or doubtful receivables,
- in this context, whether your Company can benefit from the fee exemption under Law No. 4691 and related legislation for the assignment fee for receivables to be assigned, and where lawsuits and/or enforcement proceedings are initiated.
CORPORATE TAX LAW ASPECT
The first paragraph of Article 6 of Corporate Tax Law No. 5520 provides that corporate tax is calculated on the net corporate income obtained by taxpayers in an accounting period, and the second paragraph that the provisions of the Income Tax Law on commercial income apply in determining net corporate income.
Article 38, titled "Determination of Commercial Income on the Balance Sheet Basis", of the Income Tax Law provides that commercial income on the balance sheet basis is the positive difference between the values of equity in the enterprise at the end and beginning of the accounting period, that values added to the business by the owner or owners during this period are deducted from this difference and values withdrawn from the business are added to it, and that in determining commercial income in this way the valuation provisions of the Tax Procedure Law and the provisions of Articles 40 and 41 of this Law are complied with.
Two basic principles apply in determining commercial income: the "accrual principle" and the "periodicity principle". Under the accrual principle, income or expense must be final in amount and nature, so that, in addition to the transaction giving rise to the income or expense being completed, its amount and the payment terms of the receivable or payable arising from the transaction must also be determined. Considering this principle, unless there is a special provision, an income or expense item must be taken into account in determining income for the period in which it becomes final in nature and amount. Under the "periodicity" concept, businesses must account for their income and expenses on the accrual basis and match their revenue, income and profits with costs, expenses and losses of the same period. Under this principle, income and expenses must be recorded in the period to which they relate.
According to these provisions and explanations, for accrued income to exist, the income must be final in nature and amount and the payment terms of the receivable arising from the transaction must be determined.
Accordingly, in the specific case, considering that due to the legal disputes a … was signed between your Company and … on …, that if … conditions occur … will assign to your Company, for a price of …, approximately … of its receivable, out of the total principal and ancillary receivables arising from the loan it extended to … which it could not/considers it cannot collect, together with the related collateral, and that …'s tax registration has been closed ex officio, no accrued income exists in this case, and therefore the difference between the assigned amount and the payment made will not be taken into account as income in determining your corporate income.
On the other hand, it is natural that where, with the rent amounts collected, collections are made in subsequent periods in an amount exceeding the receivable you acquired by assignment for a price of …, the excess amounts must be included in your corporate income in the relevant periods.
FEES LAW ASPECT
Article 2 of Fees Law No. 492 provides that judicial transactions listed in Tariff (1) annexed to this law are subject to judicial fees; Article 11 that judicial fees are generally payable by persons filing the lawsuit or requesting the transaction subject to the fee; and the first paragraph of Article 123 that no fee is charged from persons exempted from fees by special laws or for transactions exempted.
On the other hand, subparagraph (k) of the first paragraph of Article 3 of Technology Development Zones Law No. 4691 provides that "Management Company" means the company established as a joint stock company in accordance with this Law and responsible for managing and operating the zone; and the third paragraph of Article 8 provides that the management company is exempt from stamp duty for documents drawn up and from fees for transactions made relating to the application of this Law; the management company has no fee exemption for transactions made outside the application of this Law.
Accordingly, since judicial transactions such as filing lawsuits or initiating enforcement proceedings by your company relating to the receivables acquired by assignment from the bank subject to your application cannot be treated as transactions of the management company relating to the application of Law No. 4691, it is not possible for you to benefit from the fee exemption in Article 8 of Law No. 4691 for these transactions.
For your information.
Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.