A company leases ships registered in the Turkish International Ship Registry (TUGS) from shipping companies on bareboat terms and, appointing the master and crew itself, carries freight with these ships under time-based charter contracts. It asked what VAT rate applies to this service and whether the corporate tax exemption applies.
The Administration's view:
- The activity under the time-based contract is time-charter operation and counts as ship operation; the company can use the TUGS exemption in Article 12 of Law No. 4490.
- Since this activity is not a lease but an undertaking of carriage, the 1% rate in item B/15 of List (I) annexed to the BKK does not apply; VAT is calculated at the general rate (18% before 10/7/2023, 20% after) on the whole price.
The ruling is relevant to shipping companies leasing ships and operating time charters. The regulation provision that ships under bareboat charter cannot be registered in TUGS is quoted in the ruling but not separately tied to its conclusion.
Full text
Subject: Taxation of hiring out a leased TUGS-registered ship for freight carriage
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.
Reference: a) Your ruling request form dated ..... with document registration number …... b) Your ruling request form dated …. with document registration number …...
In the ruling request forms referred to above, stating that you lease ships registered in TUGS under "Bareboat (Bare) Charter Contracts" made with shipping companies carrying out domestic and international freight carriage, and that you carry freight with the ships you have leased under "Time Charter Contracts" drawn up between ….. A.Ş. and your company, with the master and crew appointed by your company, our Directorate's opinion is requested on the value added tax (VAT) rate to be applied to the carriage service and the corporate tax exemption.
CORPORATE TAX LAW
Article 6 of Corporate Tax Law No. 5520, headed "Net corporate profit", provides that corporate tax is calculated on the net corporate profit earned by taxpayers within an accounting period and that the provisions of the Income Tax Law on commercial profit apply in determining net corporate profit.
Article 38 of Income Tax Law No. 193 provides that commercial profit on the balance sheet basis is the positive difference between the values of the equity of the enterprise at the end and beginning of the accounting period, that values added to the business by the owner or owners during this period are deducted from this difference and values withdrawn from the business are added to it, and that in determining commercial profit in this way the valuation provisions of the Tax Procedure Law and the provisions of Articles 40 and 41 of this Law are complied with.
Furthermore, Article 2 of Turkish International Ship Registry Law No. 4490 provides that the concept of ship in this Law means all kinds of cargo, passenger and deep-sea fishing ships and special-purpose and specially built ships used for commercial purposes in cabotage and/or non-cabotage waters, and Article 12 provides that profits from operating and transferring ships and yachts registered in the Turkish International Ship Registry created under this Law are exempt from income and corporate taxes and funds.
Section "5.12.1.1. Legal provision and scope of the exemption" of Corporate Tax General Communiqué Serial No. 1, which contains explanations on the exemption for profits from operating and transferring ships registered in the Turkish International Ship Registry, states:
"Paragraph (1) of Article 12, as amended by Article 3 of Law No. 5266, of Law No. 4490 on the Turkish International Ship Registry and on Amendment of Decree Law No. 491 provides: "Profits from operating and transferring ships and yachts registered in the Turkish International Ship Registry created under this Law are exempt from income and corporate taxes and funds."
Under this provision, profits from operating ships and yachts registered in the Turkish International Ship Registry created by Law No. 4490 will be exempt from income tax where the activity is carried out by income taxpayers (including limited liable ones) and from corporate tax where carried out by corporate taxpayers (including limited liable ones); profits from transferring ships registered in the Turkish International Ship Registry will also be exempt from income and corporate tax.
This exemption is limited to profits earned by natural and legal persons from operating and transferring ships and yachts they have registered in the Turkish International Ship Registry. However, profits from transferring ships and yachts built in Türkiye that are registered in that Registry will also be treated as within the exemption regardless of whether they are operated. ..."
and sub-section "5.12.1.6. Time-charter operation" of the Communiqué states:
"In maritime transport, since "Time-Charter Operation", carried out under contracts undertaking the carriage of cargo and goods by allocating all or part of the ship to the shipper based on time or cargo, is treated as within ship operation activity, the profits from these activities must be exempted from corporate tax.
However, where ships registered in the international ship registry are leased directly without dependence on time and cargo, there can be no question of ship operation activity, and the exemption will naturally not be applied to the rental income earned."
Ship hire services can be carried out in two ways:
1- Ship Lease Contract
2- Freight (Time Charter) Contract
In a freight contract, a service in the form of carriage work is provided to the main carrier firm undertaking the carriage, and the ship is not leased to the main carrier. Since part or all of the ship is allocated for carrying cargo within a certain period, in time charter contracts the price is determined not for carrying a specific cargo but for carrying cargo within a certain period. As can be understood from these explanations, what is involved here is not the lease of the ship but the undertaking of carriage.
Article 1119 of Turkish Commercial Code No. 6102 defines a ship lease contract as a contract in which the lessor undertakes to leave the use of the ship to the lessee for a certain period in return for rent, and the following articles provide that the lessee may use the ship as it wishes, in accordance with its intended purpose and within the contract provisions, and that all debts and obligations arising from employing the crew belong to the lessee.
In addition, Article 4 of the Turkish International Ship Registry Regulation states: "Bareboat charter means a charter enabling a ship under one country's flag to pass temporarily to another country's flag under the responsibility of a shipowner/operator, in which by whom and to what extent the ship's expenses will be borne is subject to special agreements.", and the same Regulation states that ships and yachts under bareboat charter cannot be registered in TUGS.
Under these provisions and explanations, since the transfer (lease) of ships registered in the Turkish International Ship Registry to ….. A.Ş. under the "Time Charter Contract" annexed to the ruling request form will be treated as ship operation activity within time-charter operation, your company may benefit from that exemption.
VALUE ADDED TAX LAW
VAT rates applied to supplies of goods and services are determined, on the authority given by Article 28 of VAT Law No. 3065 and within the limits set out in that article, by the Council of Ministers before the amendment by Decree Law No. 700 and by the President after it.
In this context, VAT rates were applied at 1% for supplies and services in List (I) annexed to Council of Ministers Decision (BKK) No. 2007/13033, 8% for supplies and services in List (II), and 18% for taxable transactions not in these lists; by Presidential Decision No. 7346, published in Official Gazette No. 32241 dated 7/7/2023 and entering into force on 10/7/2023, this rate was set at 10% for supplies and services in List (II) and 20% for taxable transactions not in the relevant lists, while no change was made to the VAT rate for supplies and services in List (I).
Item 15 of section "B) OTHER GOODS AND SERVICES" of List (I) annexed to that BKK lists "leasing of vehicles whose supplies are exempt from value added tax under Article 13(1)(a) of Value Added Tax Law No. 3065 to taxpayers whose activities consist wholly or partly of leasing or otherwise operating these vehicles ...", providing for this service to be taxed at 1%.
In this framework, for a vehicle leasing service to be subject to VAT at 1% under item 15 of section "B) OTHER GOODS AND SERVICES" of List (I) annexed to the BKK, the following conditions must be met together:
1) the subject of the lease contract must be a vehicle whose supply is exempt from VAT under Article 13(1)(a) of the VAT Law,
2) the lease must be made to taxpayers whose activities consist wholly or partly of leasing or otherwise operating these vehicles,
3) the transaction must be a lease transaction.
Accordingly, since your activities under the "Time Charter Contract" signed between ….. A.Ş. and your company, containing an undertaking of hire based on time and cargo, will be treated as "Time-Charter Operation", VAT must be calculated at the general rate (18% before 10/7/2023, 20% from that date) on the whole price for that activity, which cannot be accepted as within item 15 of section "B) OTHER GOODS AND SERVICES" of List (I) annexed to BKK No. 2007/13033.
For your information.
Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.