TREN
Contact us

Calculating VAT to Be Added Back at a Foundation University Running Both Taxable Education and Exempt Hospital Services

VAT · ExemptionsCalculating VAT to Be Added Back at a Foundation University Running Both Taxable Education and Exempt Hospital ServicesPrivate ruling · 9 August 2024
Rast note

A foundation university whose education activities are subject to VAT while its training and research hospital services are exempt under VATL Art. 17/2-a, noting that goods and services bought by the hospital unit are also used by faculty, students and administrative staff, asked how "VAT to Be Added" is to be calculated on the return.

The Administration's view:

  • Those carrying out transactions with and without deduction rights record all input VAT as deductible; VAT to be added back is found by applying the ratio of exempt transactions to total transactions in the period to the VAT borne.
  • For goods and services bought by the hospital unit relating to both education and hospital services, VAT to be added back is determined by this ratio method.
  • VAT on purchases directly related to exempt hospital services is removed from deductible VAT and declared on the "Addition of VAT Previously Deducted" line; VAT on items bought by the hospital unit but used directly in education is treated as VAT borne for education.

The ruling is relevant to universities, hospitals and other institutions running both taxable and exempt activities.

ShareLinkedInWhatsAppEmail

Full text

Subject: How a university carrying out transactions with and without deduction rights calculates VAT to be added back
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.

In your ruling request form referred to above, stating:

- that you operate as a foundation university, that besides your education activities your University also has a training and research hospital, and that as a health university you carry out the theoretical and practical training of the academic process you run on an applied basis at different locations, setting up the management, organisation, coordination, accounting, finance and staff of each location separately,

- that service invoices issued by your Training and Research Hospital unit are issued as exempt under Article 17/2-a of the Value Added Tax (VAT) Law, that the education period at the main education campus takes place within 9 months and services in this period are invoiced, that in holiday periods when education is suspended you generally invoice occasional education services and repair and renovation works, and that you issue invoices with VAT for the education services provided since they are subject to VAT under the general principles,

- that the financial information arising in each service unit is collected and combined under a single tax number and VAT and withholding returns are filed, but that goods or services bought by the hospital unit are made available for use by patients and their relatives as well as by teaching staff, students and administrative personnel,

our Presidency's opinion is requested on how "VAT to Be Added" is to be calculated on VAT returns since your University's education activities are subject to VAT and your training and research hospital services are exempt from VAT.

VAT Law No. 3065 provides:

- in Article 17/2-a, that deliveries and services in line with their founding purposes carried out by the institutions and organisations listed in Article 17/1 of the Law by operating or managing hospitals are exempt from VAT,

- in Article 29, that, unless otherwise provided in this Law, taxpayers may deduct from the VAT calculated on their taxable transactions the VAT shown in invoices and similar documents issued for deliveries and services made to them relating to their activities, in the tax period in which the related documents are recorded in the statutory books, provided that the calendar year following the calendar year in which the taxable event occurred is not exceeded,

- in Article 30/a, that VAT shown in purchase documents relating to the delivery of goods and supply of services not subject to tax or exempt from tax, or included in the costs of these goods and services, cannot be deducted from the VAT calculated on the taxpayer's taxable transactions,

- in Article 33, that where transactions with deduction rights and transactions without deduction rights are carried out together, only the portion of the VAT shown in invoices and similar documents attributable to transactions with deduction rights is deducted.

Section (III.C.4.) titled "Partial Tax Deduction" of the VAT General Application Communiqué states:

"Taxpayers carrying out transactions with and without deduction rights together transfer the taxes borne on their purchases entirely to the deductible VAT account in that period without any distinction. Then, in the same period, the ratio of transactions without deduction rights within total sales is found, and this ratio is applied to the taxes borne due to total sales in that period to calculate the amount of tax borne due to transactions within the exemption. The taxes borne relating to tax-free sales (transactions within partial exemption) found in this way are entered on the "VAT to Be Added" line of the VAT return.
Taxpayers carrying out transactions with and without deduction rights together will separate, according to the principles in this section, the taxes they bore on common general expenses and depreciable economic assets into those to be deducted and those not to be deducted but transferred to expense accounts."

On the other hand, where goods and services bought by the hospital unit relate to both taxable education activities and exempt hospital services, the amount of tax borne due to transactions within the exemption (VAT to be added) will be determined by finding the ratio of exempt transactions within total transactions in the relevant period and applying this ratio to the taxes borne on spending on goods and services.

Accordingly, where goods and services bought by the hospital unit relate directly to hospital services exempt from VAT, the VAT borne on these goods and services must be removed from the deductible VAT accounts and declared by including it on the "Addition of VAT Previously Deducted" line of VAT Return No. 1 for the relevant period. VAT borne on goods and services procured by the hospital unit but used directly in taxable education activities must be taken into account as VAT borne relating to education activities.

For your information.

(*) This ruling has been issued under Article 413 of Tax Procedure Law No. 213.
(**) This ruling is invalid if incorrect information has been provided on this matter while it is under tax examination, judicial review or settlement.
(***) If you act in accordance with this ruling issued at your request and tax has to be assessed as a result, no tax penalty will be imposed on you and no late payment interest will be calculated on the tax assessed.

Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.