TREN
Contact us

Banking Law Art. 143 fee exemption on the transfer of immovables to an asset management company

Fees · Title deed feesBanking Law Art. 143 fee exemption on the transfer of immovables to an asset management companyPrivate ruling · 8 May 2024
Rast note

An asset management company asked whether the transfer to it, under a separate promise-to-transfer agreement linked to protocols and agreements under which it took over bank receivables, of immovables previously transferred by debtors to a creditor under a restructuring, is exempt from fees under Article 143 of Law No. 5411.

The Administration's view:

  • Acquisitions and disposals of immovables by asset management companies for the purpose of collecting receivables taken over from banks and other financial institutions including the SDIF are exempt from fees; transfers not aimed at that purpose are outside the scope.
  • The immovables were transferred in 2021 and 2022 under the 2021 Financial Restructuring Agreement, and their transfer to the company was undertaken by a separate agreement apart from the transfer of the bank receivables.
  • Since this transfer is not a transaction aimed at collecting the receivables of financial institutions, it cannot be exempted from fees under Article 143.

The ruling is relevant to asset management companies acquiring immovables in connection with receivable transfers.

ShareLinkedInWhatsAppEmail

Full text

Subject: Land registry fee exemption for transactions of an asset management company
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.

Upon review of the ruling request form and its annexes referred to above, it is understood that, stating that the immovables registered under parcel numbers … and the immovable registered under parcel number … in the name of … will be transferred to your company under the protocol concluded between your company and the debtor companies regarding the assignment of receivables and the assignment agreement and promise-to-transfer agreement concluded between your company and …, an opinion is requested on whether these transfers are exempt from fees under Article 143 of Banking Law No. 5411.

Article 57 of Fees Law No. 492 provides that land registry and cadastre transactions listed in Tariff (4) annexed to the Law are subject to land registry and cadastre fees; the second paragraph of Article 63 provides that in transfers and acquisitions of immovables the land registry and cadastre fee is calculated on the declared transfer and acquisition price, not less than the property tax value; and paragraph I/20-a of Tariff (4) provides that in transfers and acquisitions of immovables against consideration, under a life-care contract or by exchange, a proportional fee is charged separately for the transferor and the transferee.

The first paragraph of Article 123 of the same Law provides that no fee is charged from persons exempted from fees by special laws or for exempted transactions.

On the other hand, the first paragraph of Article 143 of Banking Law No. 5411 provides: "Asset management companies, whose establishment and operating principles are determined by the Board, may also be established for the purpose of purchasing, collecting, restructuring and selling receivables and other assets of banks and other financial institutions including the Fund. Asset management companies are authorized to carry out all kinds of activities, including operating, leasing and investing in immovables or other goods, rights and assets acquired for the purpose of collecting receivables within the scope of collecting their receivables and restructuring receivables and/or other assets, and also providing additional financing to their debtors or participating in their capital in order to collect their receivables." The sixth paragraph, as amended by Article 58 of Law No. 7338 dated 14/10/2021, provides: "Transactions carried out by asset management companies established under this Law and by asset management companies established under the regulation issued by the Board pursuant to the seventh paragraph of Article 3 of Law No. 4743 on the Restructuring of Debts to the Financial Sector and Amendments to Certain Laws, repealed by this Law, and the papers issued in connection therewith, are exempt from stamp duty payable under Stamp Duty Law No. 488, fees payable under Fees Law No. 492, deductions to the resource utilization support fund and the provision of Article 39 of Law No. 4054 on the Protection of Competition."

Under Article 143 of Law No. 5411, acquisitions of immovables by asset management companies established under this Law and under the regulation issued by the Board pursuant to the seventh paragraph of Article 3 of Law No. 4743 (repealed by Law No. 5411) for the purpose of collecting receivables taken over from banks and other financial institutions including the SDIF, and disposals of these immovables, are exempt from fees; immovable transfers not aimed at collecting such receivables cannot be considered within the scope of this law.

From the review of the application annexes, it is understood that:

- a Protocol was signed between your company and … on … for your company to take over by transfer and assignment the loan receivables of … from debtors and the immovables under parcel numbers … and parcel number … transferred to … under a repurchase (vefa) arrangement, to restructure the loan receivable to be assigned, and, upon completion of payments, to settle the debt and transfer the immovables to the debtors or to third parties designated by them;
- a "Receivable Transfer Agreement" dated … and numbered … was signed between … and your company, under which it was agreed that the bank's cash receivables from the counterparties (those liable for the debt: …) specified in Article 1 of the agreement, the mortgage rights established in favour of the Bank to secure these receivables and the enforcement proceedings relating to bills of exchange endorsed to the Bank would be transferred to the transferee in accordance with the agreement;
- by the paper titled "Agreement" drawn up between … and your company on …, it was undertaken that, provided the assignment price agreed in the "Receivable Transfer Agreement" has been paid in full and on time by … to … and the immovable transfer prices have been paid, the immovables under parcel numbers … and parcel number … would be transferred by … to your company, and your company undertook to take over these immovables;
- on the other hand, in the article "6.1.8. Transfer of Immovables to Creditor Institutions against the Debt and Granting of a Repurchase (vefa) Right to the Owners of the Immovables to Be Transferred" of the "… Restructuring Agreement" concluded between the loan debtors (…), the creditor institutions and the joint guarantors, it was undertaken that the immovables under parcel numbers … and parcel number … would be transferred against the debt owed to the creditor institution and that, subject to fulfilment of the conditions and obligations set out in the agreement, a repurchase right would be granted to their former owners or to third persons and firms designated by them.

In addition, from the review of the land registry records obtained from the … Land Registry Directorates, it was seen that ownership of the immovable under parcel number … was registered in the name of … on …, ownership of the immovables under parcel numbers … on …, and ownership of the immovable under parcel number … on ….

Accordingly, although the bank's cash receivables from the counterparties (those liable for the debt), the mortgage rights established in favour of the Bank to secure these receivables and the enforcement proceedings relating to bills of exchange endorsed to the Bank have been transferred to your company by the "Receivable Transfer Agreement" signed between your company and … on …, considering that the immovables subject to your application were transferred to … in 2021 and 2022 under the Financial Restructuring Agreement concluded in 2021 between the creditor banks and the debtor companies, and that, apart from the transfer of the bank receivables, … undertook to transfer these immovables to your company under a separate agreement between … and your company, the transactions for the transfer of these immovables by … to your company cannot be considered as transactions aimed at collecting the receivables of banks and other financial institutions including the Fund; therefore they cannot be exempted from fees under Article 143 of Law No. 5411.

Kindly be informed.

(*) This ruling has been issued under Article 413 of Tax Procedure Law No. 213.
(**) This ruling is invalid if incorrect information has been provided on this matter while it is under tax examination, judicial review or settlement.
(***) If you act in accordance with this ruling issued at your request and tax has to be assessed as a result, no tax penalty will be imposed on you and no late payment interest will be calculated on the tax assessed.

Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.