A private education company made an exam centre agreement with a foreign-based educational institution; it will collect exam fees across Türkiye, keep a share and send the rest abroad. It asked about invoicing and its CT and VAT obligations.
The Administration's view:
- Due to the activities the company carries on for the foreign firm, a permanent establishment (dependent agent under DTT Art. 5/5) arises for the foreign firm in Türkiye; the foreign firm must declare its Turkish income on a corporate tax return, and tax paid in Türkiye is credited in the other country.
- The company's commission income from the exam service is part of its own corporate income.
- The foreign firm's services in Türkiye are subject to VAT, declared by that firm; the exam service the company provides to the foreign firm is also subject to VAT at the general rate.
- The company issues invoices or retail sales documents to exam applicants; amounts transferred to the foreign firm are documented by an invoice the foreign firm issues to the company.
The ruling is relevant to education institutions organising exams in Türkiye for foreign bodies.
Full text
Subject: CT and VAT treatment of fees collected under an agreement with a foreign-based educational institution
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.
In the ruling request form referred to above, stating that:
- your business operating as a private education institution made an exam centre agreement with an educational institution based in …,
- under the agreement, exam participation fees will be collected throughout Türkiye by your business, …% of the collections will remain with your institution, and the remaining amount will be sent to the business based in … at the end of the exam period,
- advertising and other expenses incurred by your business during this process to announce and promote the exam will be covered from the fees collected, and invoices and similar documents for these expenses will be issued in the name of the business based in …,
- the contract with that firm states that corporate tax will be paid by …,
our Presidency's opinion is requested on whether the fees to be collected are to be invoiced and what is to be done in terms of corporate tax and value added tax.
IN TERMS OF THE CORPORATE TAX LAW:
Corporate Tax Law No. 5520 provides:
- in Article 3:
"... (2) Limited liability: Entities listed in Article 1 of the Law whose legal and business centres are both outside Türkiye are taxed only on income earned in Türkiye.
(3) Under limited liability, corporate income consists of the following income and gains:
a) Business income obtained by foreign entities having a place of business or permanent representative in Türkiye in accordance with Tax Procedure Law No. 213 dated 4/1/1961 from work done in these places or through these representatives (even if they meet these conditions, gains from entities sending goods bought in Türkiye for export to foreign countries without selling them in Türkiye are not deemed earned in Türkiye. Selling in Türkiye means the buyer or seller or both being in Türkiye or the sales contract being made in Türkiye.)
..."
- in Article 22:
"(1) In determining the income of limited liability entities obtained through a place of business or permanent representative, unless otherwise stated, the provisions applicable to fully liable entities apply.
(2) For income and gains of limited liability entities other than business or agricultural income, the provisions of the Income Tax Law on determining these income and gains apply. However, where these income and gains are obtained within business or agricultural activity carried on in Türkiye, corporate income is determined under the first paragraph of this article..."
- in the fourth paragraph of Article 25:
"The annual corporate tax return is filed with the tax office of the place where the entity's place of business or permanent representative in Türkiye is located; if there is no place of business or permanent representative in Türkiye, with the tax office to which those providing income to the foreign entity are attached."
- in the first paragraph of Article 28:
"Tax of foreign entities subject to limited liability is assessed on their behalf in the name of their managers or representatives in Türkiye; if there are no managers or representatives, in the name of those providing income and gains to the foreign entity."
According to these provisions and explanations, since a place of business in Türkiye is deemed to arise for the firm resident in … due to the activities your Company carries on on behalf of the firm resident in …, the firm resident in … must fulfil its tax obligations relating to income earned in Türkiye in this scope and declare the income on a corporate tax return.
On the other hand, it goes without saying that the commission income obtained in return for the exam service performed in Türkiye on behalf of the firm resident in … must be included in your company's corporate income.
IN TERMS OF DOUBLE TAX TREATIES:
The "Agreement between the Republic of Türkiye and … for the Avoidance of Double Taxation and the Prevention of Fiscal Evasion with respect to Taxes on Income and on Capital" has been applied from 01.01.2012, and paragraph 1 of Article 7 on "Business Profits" of that Agreement provides:
"1. The profits of an enterprise of a Contracting State shall be taxable only in that State unless the enterprise carries on business in the other Contracting State through a permanent establishment situated therein. If the enterprise carries on business as aforesaid, the profits of the enterprise may be taxed in the other State but only so much of them as is attributable to that permanent establishment."
Paragraph 5 of Article 5 on "Permanent establishment" of the Agreement regulates dependent agency. Under this paragraph, if a person acts in a Contracting State on behalf of an enterprise of the other Contracting State and carries on the activities specified in that paragraph on behalf of the enterprise it represents, these activities will constitute a permanent establishment for the enterprise of the other Contracting State.
Under these provisions, Türkiye has the right to tax, under paragraph 5 of Article 5 of the Agreement, the income obtained from the activities the Türkiye-resident company carries on on behalf of the company resident in …, and taxation will be made under our domestic legislation. Also, under subparagraph (a) of paragraph 1 of Article 23 on "Elimination of Double Taxation" of the Agreement, double taxation will be avoided by crediting the tax so paid in Türkiye for those payments against the tax to be paid in … on this income.
IN TERMS OF THE VALUE ADDED TAX LAW:
Value Added Tax (VAT) Law No. 3065 provides:
- in Article 1/1, that deliveries and services made in Türkiye within commercial, industrial, agricultural and self-employment activity are subject to VAT,
- in Article 8, that in cases of delivery of goods and performance of services, those doing the work are the taxpayers.
On the other hand, VAT rates were applied, under Council of Ministers Decision No. 2007/13033 issued under the authority given to the Council of Ministers by Article 28 of the VAT Law, at 1% for goods and services in list I, 8% for goods and services in list II, and 18% for taxable transactions not in these lists; by Presidential Decision No. 7346 published in Official Gazette No. 32241 dated 07/07/2023, to apply from 10/07/2023, the VAT rate for deliveries and services in list (II) was changed to "10%" and that for taxable transactions not in these lists to "20%".
In this framework, since under the Double Tax Treaty signed between the Republic of Türkiye and … a place of business in Türkiye is deemed to arise for the firm resident in … due to the activities your Company carries on on behalf of the firm resident in …, the services provided in Türkiye by the firm resident in … are subject to VAT under Article 1/1 of VAT Law No. 3065, and the VAT in invoices issued for those services must be declared and paid by that firm.
On the other hand, the exam service provided by your Company to the firm resident in …, which has a place of business in Türkiye, is subject to VAT, and VAT at the general rate of 18% (20% from 10/07/2023) must be calculated on the exam service fee provided to this firm.
IN TERMS OF THE TAX PROCEDURE LAW:
Tax Procedure Law No. 213 provides:
- in the first paragraph of Article 227:
"Unless otherwise provided in this law, it is mandatory to document records kept under this law relating to relations and transactions with third parties."
- in Article 229:
"An invoice is a commercial document given to the customer by the merchant selling the goods or doing the work to show the amount the customer owes in return for goods sold or work done."
- in subparagraph (5) of the first paragraph of Article 231:
"5. The invoice is issued within at most seven days from the date of delivery of the goods or performance of the service. The Ministry of Treasury and Finance is authorised to shorten this period or require the invoice to be issued at the time of delivery or performance, taking into account separately or together the type, quantity, price and amount of the goods or service, the manner of sale, field of activity, sector or type of tax liability. Invoices not issued within these periods are deemed never issued."
- in Article 232:
"First and second class merchants, those whose income is determined under the simple method and farmers obliged to keep books are obliged to give invoices for goods they sell or work they do to, and to request and receive invoices from:
1. First and second class merchants;
2. Self-employed professionals;
3. Merchants whose income is determined under the simple method;
4. Farmers obliged to keep books;
5. Tradesmen exempt from tax.
For others, where the price of goods purchased from or work commissioned to first and second class merchants, those whose income is determined under the simple method and farmers obliged to keep books exceeds 50,000,000 lira (TL 6,900 from 1.1.2024 under Tax Procedure Law General Communiqué No. 556), or even if less than that if they request it, the seller of the goods or doer of the work must give an invoice."
- in Article 233:
"Prices of sales and work done by first and second class merchants, those whose income is determined under the simple method and farmers obliged to keep books for which they are not obliged to give invoices are documented by any of the following documents.
1. Retail sales receipts;
2. Cash register rolls;
3. Admission and passenger tickets.
... Where a cash register is used and no receipt (a cash register receipt containing the information in the previous paragraph) is given to the customer, a retail sales receipt must be issued and given to the customer."
Accordingly;
1- An invoice, or a retail sales document (retail sales receipt, cash register receipt) where there is no obligation to issue an invoice, must be issued by your Company under general provisions on the exam service fee in the name of those served (those applying to sit the exam).
2- Amounts transferred from the exam fee to the company resident in … in relation to that exam service must be documented by an invoice to be issued in your name by that company.
For your information.
Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.