TREN
Contact us

Managers and Partners of the Contractor Being Members of a Building Cooperative Does Not Breach the Exemption; Sitting on Its Management or Audit Board Does

Corporate Income TaxManagers and Partners of the Contractor Being Members of a Building Cooperative Does Not Breach the Exemption; Sitting on Its Management or Audit Board DoesPrivate ruling · 12 July 2024
Rast note

A housing building cooperative asked whether its corporate tax exemption is breached because the partners of the limited company undertaking the construction are also cooperative members.

The Administration's view:

  • In addition to the general conditions, building cooperatives must not include on their management and audit boards, from formation to completion of construction, those undertaking the construction, persons related to them under CTL 13 or those in an employee-employer relationship with them, and the permit and title must be in the cooperative's name.
  • The managers and partners of the contractor being members of the cooperative does not affect the exemption.
  • However, if these persons or related persons sit on the cooperative's management or audit board until construction ends, the exemption cannot be benefited from.

The ruling is relevant to building cooperatives with links between the contractor and members.

ShareLinkedInWhatsAppEmail

Full text

Subject: Whether the exemption is breached where managers of the firm building for a housing cooperative are also cooperative members
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.

…

In the ruling request form referred to above, stating that the cooperative operates as a housing building cooperative under the name … Housing Building Cooperative, that a subcontracting agreement was made with … Ltd. Şti. on …, that the building permit was obtained in the Cooperative's name on … and construction began on …, and that the partners of that company are also members of the cooperative, our Presidency's opinion is requested on whether the cooperative will have corporate tax liability.

Although cooperatives are listed among corporate taxpayers by the second paragraph of Article 2 of Corporate Tax Law No. 5520, subparagraph (k) of the first paragraph of Article 4 of the same Law provides that, excluding consumer and transport cooperatives, cooperatives whose articles of association contain provisions on not distributing profit on capital, not giving shares of profit to the chairman and members of the board of directors, not distributing reserves to partners and doing business only with partners (building cooperatives obtaining one workplace or residence for each share by giving their own land in return for flats is not deemed a non-member transaction. A separate economic enterprise attached to the cooperative legal entity is deemed to arise due to non-member transactions of cooperatives. Cooperatives obtaining profits from their economic enterprises and from participating in the capital of another fully liable entity, and later distributing these profits to partners, does not affect the exemption. The procedures and principles for taxing profits from non-member transactions are determined by the Ministry of Finance.) and which actually comply with these provisions, and building cooperatives that, in addition to these restrictions and conditions, from formation until completion of construction do not include on their management and audit boards natural persons or representatives of legal persons undertaking the construction work in whole or in part, or persons deemed related to them under Article 13 of the Law, or those in an employee-employer relationship with them, and whose building permit and land title are registered in the name of the cooperative legal entity, are exempt from corporate tax.

Accordingly, for building cooperatives to benefit from the exemption, their articles of association must contain provisions on:

- Not distributing profit on capital,
- Not giving shares of profit to the chairman and members of the board of directors,
- Not distributing reserves to partners,
- Doing business only with partners (building cooperatives obtaining one workplace or residence for each share by giving their own land in return for flats is not deemed a non-member transaction),

and these provisions must actually be complied with.

On the other hand, for building cooperatives, in addition to the conditions above, the conditions of not including on their management and audit boards, from formation until completion of construction, natural persons or representatives of legal persons undertaking the construction work in whole or in part, or persons deemed related to them under Article 13 of the Law, or persons in an employee-employer relationship with them, and of having the building permit and land title registered in the name of the cooperative legal entity, are also required.

The section titled "4.13.2. Special conditions for the exemption of building cooperatives" of Corporate Tax General Communiqué Serial No. 1, which contains detailed explanations on the matter, states:

"...
- From their formation until completion of construction, their management and audit boards must not include natural persons or representatives of legal persons undertaking the construction work in whole or in part, and persons related to them under Article 13 of the Corporate Tax Law or persons in an employee-employer relationship,
- The building permit and land title must be in the name of the cooperative legal entity.
Accordingly, for building cooperatives to benefit from the exemption, from formation until completion of construction, their management and audit boards must not include natural persons or representatives of legal persons undertaking the construction, persons and entities deemed related to them, or those in an employee-employer relationship with them.
The related person referred to here covers, for the natural and legal persons undertaking the construction:
- their partners,
- natural and legal persons with which their partners are connected,
- natural and legal persons to which their partners are directly or indirectly attached in terms of management, control or capital or which they hold under their influence,
- spouses of their partners,
- ascendants and descendants of their partners or their spouses and collateral relatives up to and including the third degree and in-laws.
Building cooperatives cannot benefit from the exemption where the building permit or land title is not in the name of the cooperative legal entity. For example, a building permit issued in the name of the contractor undertaking the construction will prevent the building cooperative from benefiting from the exemption. These conditions will not be sought for cooperatives that have not yet reached the stage of land supply or construction and therefore have no activity aimed at providing workplaces or residences. For example, the condition relating to the construction permit will not be sought from a housing building cooperative whose land title belongs to the cooperative legal entity but which has not yet reached the construction stage..."

According to these provisions and explanations, the managers and partners of … Ltd. Şti., with which you signed a construction agreement, being members of your Cooperative will not affect the exemption conditions of your Cooperative.

However, if the managers and partners of that Company and persons related to them or persons in an employee-employer relationship with them sit on the management and audit boards of your Cooperative until construction ends, it is not possible for you to benefit from the exemption provision.

For your information.

Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.