A taxpayer who makes wooden products at home and exports them via ETSY as micro-exports, benefiting from the ITL 89/1-16 deduction, will also sell digital files of drawings made with design software to customers abroad, invoicing the non-resident customers. The taxpayer asked whether graphic design income can be deducted under ITL 89/1-13 and whether it counts toward the TL 400,000 revenue threshold in 89/1-16.
The Administration's view:
- Provided the graphic design service is actually provided and the other conditions are met together, 80% of the income from this service provided from Turkey to those abroad and used exclusively abroad can be deducted under ITL 89/1-13, on condition that all of it is transferred to Turkey by the return filing deadline.
- Under Income Tax General Communiqué No. 314, service export income is outside ITL 89/1-16; graphic design income is not counted toward the TL 400,000 revenue threshold for the micro-export deduction.
- Revenue, cost and expense items of the two activities must be tracked separately and records kept to ensure this separation.
The ruling is relevant to individual entrepreneurs doing both micro-exports and service exports.
Full text
Subject: Deduction under ITL 89/13 of income from graphic design services provided abroad and whether it is included in revenue from goods exported by courier
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.
From examination of your ruling request form referred to above, it is understood that, stating that you are a taxpayer of the … Tax Office under tax identification number … for your activity "Retail Trade via Radio, TV, Mail or Internet", that you export products such as jewellery stands and watch stands that you make from wood at your workplace used as a home office via the internet site named ETSY operating abroad within micro-exports with an electronic commerce customs declaration and benefit from the deduction under subparagraph (16) of the first paragraph of Article 89 of Income Tax Law No. 193 for the income obtained, that in addition to this activity you have been engaged in "Activities of Specialised Graphic Designers (Including Brand and Trademark Design)" since 19/12/2023 and within this activity will sell digital files of drawings you design in programs such as Adobe Photoshop and Inkscape via ETSY by sending them by e-mail to customers resident abroad, and that the invoice for the graphic design service will be issued in the name of the non-resident, you request an opinion on whether the income from this graphic design service can be deducted from declared income under subparagraph (13) of the first paragraph of Article 89 of that Law and whether it is to be included in the TL 400,000 revenue limit, which is one of the conditions for benefiting from the deduction in subparagraph (16) of the first paragraph of that article; our Presidency's opinion on the matter is given below.
Subparagraph (13) of the first paragraph of Article 89 titled "Other deductions" of Income Tax Law No. 193 provides:
"80% of the income obtained exclusively from these activities by service businesses operating in architecture, engineering, design, software, medical reporting, bookkeeping, call centre, product testing, certification, data storage, data processing, data analysis and vocational training fields determined by the Ministry of Finance upon the opinion of the relevant ministries, provided in Turkey to persons not resident in Turkey and to those whose place of business, legal and business centre is abroad and benefited from exclusively abroad, and by businesses operating in education and health subject to the permission and supervision of the relevant ministry and serving persons not resident in Turkey (wording amended by Article 10 of Law No. 7491; effective 28.12.2023 for income and earnings obtained from 1/1/2023), provided that all of it is transferred to Turkey by the date on which the annual income tax return for the calendar year in which it was obtained must be filed. To benefit from this deduction, the invoice or similar document must be issued in the name of the client abroad. The President is authorised to reduce the rate in this subparagraph to zero or increase it up to 100% (wording amended by Article 10 of Law No. 7491; effective 28.12.2023 for income and earnings obtained from 1/1/2023) by service fields and income amounts and to reduce the income amount to be transferred to Turkey to zero or increase it up to its statutory level, and the Ministry of Finance is authorised to determine the procedures and principles for the application and supervision of this subparagraph upon the opinion of the relevant ministries."
On the other hand, Corporate Tax General Communiqué Serial No. 1, which contains explanations on the matter, states:
- in the section titled "10.5.2.1. Main field of activity written in the articles of association of companies that may benefit from the deduction":
"...
The fact that businesses providing architecture, engineering, design, software, medical reporting, bookkeeping, call centre, product testing, certification, data storage, data processing, data analysis and vocational training services determined by the Ministry of Finance upon the opinion of the relevant ministries, and businesses operating in education or health subject to the permission and supervision of the Ministry of National Education and the Ministry of Health, also serve persons resident in Turkey will not prevent benefiting from the deduction..."
- in the section titled "10.5.2.2. The service being performed from Turkey exclusively for a non-resident person and/or entity":
"Architecture, engineering, design, software, medical reporting, bookkeeping, call centre, product testing, certification, data storage, data processing, data analysis and vocational training services determined by the Ministry of Finance upon the opinion of the relevant ministries must be provided to persons not resident in Turkey and to those whose place of business, legal and business centre is abroad; education or health services must be provided to persons not resident in Turkey..."
- in the section titled "10.5.2.3. The invoice being issued in the name of the non-resident person and/or entity":
"The invoice to be issued for the service performed must be issued in the name of the non-resident person and/or entity whose characteristics are explained above..."
- in the section titled "10.5.2.4. Benefiting abroad from architecture, engineering, design, software, medical reporting, bookkeeping, call centre, product testing, certification, data storage, data processing and data analysis services provided from Turkey":
"The service provided must have been benefited from abroad. In other words, the service provided for the non-resident person and/or entity must have no connection with the activities of those persons and/or entities in Turkey."
On the other hand, subparagraph (16) of the first paragraph of Article 89 of that Law provides:
"(Subparagraph added by Article 16 of Law No. 7256. Effective 17.11.2020 for income obtained from 1/1/2021) 50% of the income obtained by fully liable individuals within exports of goods made with an electronic commerce customs declaration issued by the Postal Administration or express cargo companies authorised as indirect representatives under Article 225 of Customs Law No. 4458 dated 27/10/1999. To benefit from this deduction, it is required that:
a) those whose total export revenue is up to TL 400,000 per year are themselves insured in the relevant year,
b) those whose total export revenue is up to TL 800,000 per year are themselves insured in the relevant year and employ on average at least one full-time or equivalent part-time worker,
c) those whose total export revenue is up to TL 1,600,000 per year are themselves insured in the relevant year and employ on average at least two full-time or equivalent part-time workers,
d) those whose total export revenue is up to TL 2,400,000 per year are themselves insured in the relevant year and employ on average at least three full-time or equivalent part-time workers.
(The term insured in this subparagraph refers to those deemed insured under Law No. 5510.)
The President is authorised to reduce the rates, amounts and numbers in this subparagraph by up to half and increase them up to double, and the Ministry of Treasury and Finance is authorised to determine the procedures and principles for the application of the article."
On the other hand, Article 10 titled "Taxpayers who may benefit from the deduction and conditions" of the section titled "Deduction for Income Obtained Within Exports of Goods With an Electronic Commerce Customs Declaration" of Income Tax General Communiqué Serial No. 314, which contains detailed explanations on the matter, states:
"...
(5) Taxpayers having export income in other forms besides exports of goods made with an electronic commerce customs declaration issued by the Postal Administration or express cargo companies will not prevent them from benefiting from the deduction. However, export income made in other forms by such taxpayers cannot be deducted on the return, and only income from exports of goods made within the subparagraph through the Postal Administration or express cargo companies can be deducted.
...
(6) Taxpayers who also have exports in other forms besides exports of goods made with an electronic commerce customs declaration issued by the Postal Administration or express cargo companies must track the revenue, cost and expense items of their activities separately. These taxpayers must not associate the revenue, cost and expense items of the deductible export activity with other activities and must keep their records to ensure this separation.
(7) Where export activities carried out within the conditions in that subparagraph and other activities outside this scope are carried out together, common general expenses will be allocated taking into account the ratio of revenue from deductible export activities to total revenue. Depreciation of installations, machinery and transport vehicles used jointly in activities accepted within the deduction and activities not within this scope must be allocated according to the number of days they are used in each business. Depreciation of fixed assets for which it cannot be determined how long they are used in which business will be allocated together with common general expenses.
...
(10) Income obtained within all kinds of service exports, notably software, design, architecture and engineering, is not within the scope of the regulation."
According to the above provisions and explanations, provided that you actually provide the graphic design service and meet the other conditions listed above together, it is possible for you to deduct, in determining your income tax base by showing it separately on your income tax return, 80% of your income from the graphic design service provided by you in Turkey to those abroad and benefited from exclusively abroad, on condition that all of it is transferred to Turkey by the date on which the annual income tax return for the calendar year in which it was obtained must be filed.
On the other hand, the income from the graphic design service provided by you abroad must not be included in the TL 400,000 revenue limit, which is one of the conditions for benefiting from the deduction under subparagraph (16) of the first paragraph of Article 89 of Law No. 193 within your exports of goods made by courier with an electronic commerce customs declaration; you must track the revenue, cost and expense items of your activities separately, not associate the revenue, cost and expense items of your goods export activity by courier with your graphic design activity, and keep your records to ensure this separation.
For your information.
(*) This ruling has been issued under Article 413 of Tax Procedure Law No. 213.
(**) This ruling is invalid if incorrect information has been provided on this matter while it is under tax examination, judicial review or settlement.
(***) If you act in accordance with this ruling issued at your request and tax has to be assessed as a result, no tax penalty will be imposed on you and no late payment interest will be calculated on the tax assessed.
Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.