A digital content company wholly owned by a French resident company asked whether withholding tax and reverse-charge VAT apply when the parent recharges, by turnover share, the group advertising and digital content costs it incurs.
The Administration's view:
- The recharged amounts are deductible for corporate tax if the service is needed, actually received and priced at arm's length; any excess is non-deductible and deemed a dividend distributed at period end.
- Payments for digital content sold without copyright rights are business profits under DTA Art. 7 and are not taxable in Turkey absent a permanent establishment.
- Payments for rights such as reproduction or modification are royalties; Turkey may tax them at 10%.
- Payments for specially commissioned new digital content fall under DTA Art. 14; if performed without coming to Turkey, only France may tax them.
- A certificate of residence must be submitted to apply the treaty; otherwise domestic law applies.
- Since the advertising and digital content services are benefited from in Turkey, the recharge is subject to VAT, declared in full under the reverse charge on VAT Return No. 2.
The ruling is relevant to companies receiving cost recharges from foreign group companies.
Full text
Subject: Taxation of services provided by a foreign-resident group company
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.
In the ruling request form referred to above, it is stated that your Company, engaged in selling digital content to end users through GSM operators, is wholly owned by … resident in France; that … has advertising carried out through … for its affiliates, including your Company, and the advertising fees are paid by the French resident company; that the digital content you sell is also created by …; and that … periodically invoices its affiliates for these advertising and digital content costs in proportion to their turnover. Our opinion is requested on whether income tax withholding and value added tax (VAT) withholding must be applied to payments made when these costs are recharged to your Company by the foreign resident company.
I. CORPORATE TAX LAW:
Article 3(2) of Corporate Tax Law No. 5520 provides that entities listed in Article 1 whose legal seat and business centre are both outside Turkey are taxed on a limited liability basis only on income derived in Turkey, and Article 3(3) lists the items of income constituting corporate income under limited liability.
Article 30 of the same Law provides that corporate tax is to be withheld by those paying or accruing, in cash or on account, including advances, the income items listed in the article to limited taxpayers; subparagraph (1)(b) covers self-employment income, and paragraph (2) covers amounts paid or accrued for the sale, transfer and assignment of copyrights, concessions, patents, business names, trade names, trademarks and similar intangible rights, whether or not part of commercial or agricultural income. Under Council of Ministers Decision No. 2009/14593, from … the withholding rates are 5% for income from petroleum exploration, 20% for other self-employment income and 20% for payments for the sale, transfer and assignment of such intangible rights; there is no provision for withholding on payments constituting business profits.
Furthermore, Article 13 of the Corporate Tax Law, in force since …, provides in:
- paragraph 1, that where entities buy or sell goods or services with related parties at prices determined contrary to the arm's length principle, the profit is deemed wholly or partly distributed in a disguised manner through transfer pricing, and that purchase, sale, manufacturing and construction transactions, leasing, borrowing and lending, and transactions requiring bonus, wage and similar payments are in all circumstances treated as purchases or sales of goods or services;
- paragraph 2, that related party means the entity's own shareholders, persons or entities with which the entity or its shareholders are connected, and persons or entities to which they are directly or indirectly linked, or which they control, in terms of management, supervision or capital;
- paragraph 3, that the arm's length principle means that the price applied in transactions with related parties is in line with the price that would arise between unrelated parties;
- paragraph 4, that entities determine the prices in related-party transactions using the method most appropriate to the nature of the transaction among those listed;
- paragraph 6, that profit distributed in a disguised manner through transfer pricing is deemed, for income and corporate tax purposes, a dividend distributed, or for limited taxpayers an amount transferred to head office, as of the last day of the accounting period in which the conditions are met.
The Council of Ministers Decision dated … No. …, regulating the procedures for applying this article, states that its purpose is to ensure that persons and entities buying or selling goods or services with related parties declare their income fully and correctly and to prevent erosion of the tax base through transfer pricing.
In addition, Article 11(1)(c) of the same Law, titled "Non-deductible expenses", provides that profits distributed in a disguised manner through transfer pricing are not deductible in determining corporate income.
Section 4, "Arm's Length Principle", of General Communiqué Serial No. 1 on Disguised Profit Distribution through Transfer Pricing explains that the arm's length price is the market price set by unrelated parties under the conditions prevailing at the time of the transaction, objectively determined without any influence; that the relationship between the parties should have no effect on pricing; and that where the price applied between related parties does not reflect the market price, it is deemed to be contrary to the arm's length principle.
Section 11, "Intra-Group Services", of the same Communiqué explains:
"An intra-group service means services provided between related companies, generally by a parent to its subsidiaries or by one group company to others. These services also include management, coordination and control functions for the whole group, and their cost may be borne by the parent, a group member designated for this purpose or another group member (group service centre). With respect to intra-group services, it must be determined:
- whether the service has actually been provided,
- whether the receiving company/companies need the service,
- if the service was received, whether the fee complies with the arm's length principle."
Therefore, for a service received by a related company from its parent or another group member to be accepted as an "intra-group service", the receiving company must need the service, must actually benefit from it, and the fee must be determined under the arm's length principle. However, the mere fact that payments were made to related parties for services provided by a group company and/or that the payment was described as a "management fee" does not show that the services were actually provided.
The same section also states that, in determining whether an intra-group service has been provided under the arm's length principle, it should be considered whether the service provides commercial or economic value that strengthens the recipient's commercial position, and that a company cannot be regarded as having received an intra-group service where it receives a service it does not need or where a service is provided to it merely because it is a group member.
The examples in that section also state that intra-group service costs should be allocated using an appropriate allocation key.
Article 6 of the Corporate Tax Law provides that corporate tax is calculated on net corporate income for an accounting period and that the business income provisions of the Income Tax Law apply in determining net corporate income.
Article 40(1)(1) of the Income Tax Law provides that general expenses incurred to earn and maintain business income are deductible in determining net income.
Section 8.7 of Corporate Tax General Communiqué Serial No. 1, "Allocation of holding companies' general administrative expenses to subsidiaries", states that holding companies may provide subsidiaries with services such as research and development, financing, marketing and distribution, investment project preparation, goal setting, planning, implementation of organisational decisions, IT services, management, financial audit and tax advisory, market research, public relations, recruitment and training, accounting organisation and control, and legal advisory; such services may be expensed by subsidiaries provided they were actually provided, the invoice details the type of service, and where one invoice covers several services, each fee is shown separately.
Within the framework of these explanations, provided that your Company needs the services received from the French resident group company, the services have actually been provided and the invoiced amounts are at arm's length, the amounts paid to the French resident group company may be deducted in determining corporate income. However, if these payments to the related party or the allocation keys used are contrary to the arm's length principle, the part of the payments exceeding the arm's length amount, in other words the profit distributed in a disguised manner through transfer pricing, will be added back to the period's income as a non-deductible expense and, on the other hand, deemed a dividend distributed as of the last day of the relevant accounting period.
II. DOUBLE TAXATION AVOIDANCE AGREEMENTS:
Article 12 of the Agreement between the Republic of Turkey and the French Republic for the Avoidance of Double Taxation with respect to Taxes on Income, on royalties, provides:
"1. Royalties arising in a Contracting State and paid to a resident of the other Contracting State may be taxed in that other State.
2. However, such royalties may also be taxed in the Contracting State in which they arise and according to the laws of that State, but if the recipient is the beneficial owner of the royalties, the tax so charged shall not exceed 10 per cent of the gross amount of the royalties.
3. The term "royalties" as used in this Article means payments of any kind received as a consideration for the use of, or the right to use, or the sale of, any copyright of literary, artistic or scientific work including cinematograph films and films or tapes for radio or television broadcasting, any patent, trade mark, design or model, plan, secret formula or process, or for information concerning industrial, commercial or scientific experience, and for the use of, or the right to use, industrial, commercial or scientific equipment."
Accordingly, if you sell digital content obtained from the French resident company without holding copyright rights such as modification or reproduction, the payments to the French resident company must be treated as business profits under Article 7 of the Agreement. In that case, for the French company's income from digital content sales to be taxable in Turkey, it must carry on its activities through a permanent establishment in Turkey within the meaning of Article 5 of the Agreement.
On the other hand, payments to the French resident company for the use of rights such as reproduction or modification of digital content within the scope of copyright, and other payments meeting the description in Article 12(3) of the Agreement, must be treated as royalties under that paragraph. Under Article 12(2), Turkey has the right to tax royalty payments to this company at 10%.
However, where digital content not previously available on the market is specially commissioned, payments for these services must be assessed under Article 14(2) of the Agreement on "Independent Personal Services". Accordingly, the right to tax income from independent services that the French resident company performs without coming to Turkey belongs solely to France. If these activities are performed in Turkey, Turkey also has the right to tax this income where the French resident company performs them through a place of business in Turkey within the meaning of Article 5 or where the period or periods of its activities in Turkey exceed a total of 183 days in any continuous 12-month period.
French residents wishing to benefit from the Agreement must prove, with a document obtained from the French competent authorities (certificate of residence), that they are fully liable to tax in France and taxed there on their worldwide income, and must submit the original of this document and a copy of its Turkish translation certified by a notary or by Turkish consulates in France to the withholding agents. Withholding agents will keep this document to present to the competent authorities when necessary. If the document cannot be submitted, it is natural that domestic law provisions will apply instead of the Agreement.
III. VALUE ADDED TAX LAW:
VAT Law No. 3065 provides in:
- Article 1/1, that deliveries and services made in Turkey within commercial, industrial, agricultural and self-employment activities are subject to VAT;
- Article 4, that a service is any transaction other than deliveries, deemed deliveries and imports of goods, and may take the form of doing, processing, creating, manufacturing, repairing, cleaning, storing, preparing, evaluating or leasing something, or undertaking not to do something;
- Article 6, that a transaction being carried out in Turkey means the service being performed or evaluated in Turkey or benefited from in Turkey;
- Article 9, that where the taxpayer has no residence, place of business, legal seat or business centre in Turkey, and in other cases deemed necessary, the Ministry of Treasury and Finance may hold the parties to taxable transactions liable for payment of the tax to secure the tax receivable.
Section I/C-2.1.2.1 of the VAT General Implementation Communiqué, "Transactions by those whose residence, place of business, legal seat and business centre are not in Turkey", states that a service must be performed in Turkey to fall within the scope of VAT, and under Article 6/b services performed or benefited from in Turkey are deemed performed in Turkey; services performed in Turkey by such persons, and services they perform abroad but which are benefited from in Turkey, are subject to VAT; although the taxpayer is in principle the service provider, since it has no presence in Turkey the entire VAT is declared and paid by the domestic recipient benefiting from the service as the responsible party; no VAT is declared where the service is exempt or is performed and benefited from abroad; and the recipient need not be a VAT taxpayer, as those without VAT liability must also withhold and declare and pay VAT on VAT Return No. 2.
Accordingly, the recharge to your Company of its share of the costs incurred by the French resident … for services consisting of having your Company's advertising carried out through … and creating digital content is subject to VAT because these services are benefited from in Turkey, and the entire VAT calculated must be declared and paid by your Company as the responsible party on VAT Return No. 2.
Kindly be informed.
(*) This ruling has been issued under Article 413 of Tax Procedure Law No. 213.
(**) This ruling is invalid if incorrect information has been provided on this matter while it is under tax examination, judicial review or settlement.
(***) If you act in accordance with this ruling issued at your request and tax has to be assessed as a result, no tax penalty will be imposed on you and no late payment interest will be calculated on the tax assessed.
Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.