An individual who writes games and uploads them to a foreign-based website, with earnings transferred to his account by the site, asked whether he can benefit from the exemption in Repeated Article 20/B of the Income Tax Law.
The Administration stated that, since the activity is not aimed at mobile devices such as smartphones or tablets and the income is not earned through an electronic application sharing and sales platform, the exemption cannot be used; payments from the site are taxed as commercial profit under Article 37 of the Income Tax Law.
The ruling is relevant to game and software developers earning income through platforms other than mobile app stores.
Full text
Subject: Income from game software uploaded to a foreign-based website
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.
Reference: Ruling request form dated 15/2/2024 numbered 792307
From the examination of your ruling request form referred to above, it is understood that, stating that you write games for use over the internet or on devices such as mobile devices or tablets, that in this context you upload games to a foreign-origin website named …, and that the profit you earn for your game writing service is transferred to your account by that site, you request an opinion on whether you can benefit from the profit exemption for social content creation, services provided over the internet and similar electronic media and mobile application development provided for in Repeated Article 20/B of Income Tax Law No. 193 for this activity.
Repeated Article 20/B of the Income Tax Law, headed "Profit exemption for social content creation, services provided over the internet and similar electronic media and mobile application development", provides:
"Profits earned by social content creators sharing content such as text, images, audio and video over the internet and similar electronic media from these activities, profits from services such as individual courses, training, data processing and development and product promotion provided over these media, and profits earned by those developing applications for mobile devices such as smartphones or tablets through electronic application sharing and sales platforms are exempt from income tax.
To benefit from this exemption, an account must be opened at a bank established in Türkiye and all revenue from these activities must be collected exclusively through this account.
Banks are obliged to withhold income tax at 15% on the revenue transferred to accounts opened in this context as of the transfer date and to declare and pay it under Articles 98 and 119 of the Law. No further withholding is made on this amount under Article 94.
Taxpayers having profits or income from activities outside the scope of the first paragraph does not prevent them from benefiting from the exemption.
Those whose total profits under the first paragraph exceed the amount in the fourth income bracket of the tariff in Article 103 and those who do not collect all their income from the activity in accordance with the conditions in the second paragraph cannot benefit from this exemption. Those in this situation are not subject to the obligation to withhold under the first paragraph of Article 94.
Where it is determined that the conditions for the exemption are not met, the underassessed tax is collected with a tax loss penalty and late payment interest.
The President is authorised to reduce the withholding rate in this article to zero separately for each type of activity or to re-determine it by increasing it up to twofold; the Ministry of Treasury and Finance is authorised to determine the procedures and principles for implementing the article."
Article 37 of that Law states that profits arising from all kinds of commercial and industrial activities are commercial profit. Commercial activity is based on a kind of labour-capital organisation, and whether or not there is an intention to make a profit does not affect the "commercial activity" nature of the activity carried out by such an organisation. However, although an intention to make a profit is not required for an activity to be deemed a "commercial activity", the organisation carrying out the activity must, assessed with all its elements, have the potential to make a profit.
Furthermore, explanations on the profit exemption for social content creation, services provided over the internet and similar electronic media and mobile application development are given in Income Tax General Communiqué Serial No. 318, which states:
- in Article 3, headed "Definitions":
"(1) In this Communiqué:
a) Electronic application sharing and sales platform: the platform, also known as an app store, enabling users to browse and download online mobile applications developed and published by means of software development kits,
b) Mobile application: software developed with special code and designs for mobile devices such as smartphones or tablets,
c) Mobile application developer: a natural person who develops applications to operate on electronic application sharing and sales platforms and makes the applications developed available to users on these platforms,
..."
- in Article 4, headed "Those who may benefit from the exemption, conditions and special cases in applying the exemption":
"...
(17) Within mobile application development, only profits earned through electronic application sharing and sales platforms are exempt under that article. Income earned through these platforms such as paid app sales income, advertising income, in-app sales income, sponsorship income and paid subscription income is taken into account within the exemption. On the other hand, profits earned outside electronic application sharing and sales platforms cannot be treated as within the exemption.
...
Example 20: Taxpayer (R) develops applications for computers and sells them to various customers.
Since the applications developed are not aimed at mobile devices such as smartphones or tablets and the income is not earned through electronic application sharing and sales platforms, the taxpayer cannot benefit from that exemption for these profits.
..."
Accordingly, profits earned by social content creators sharing content such as text, images, audio and video over the internet and similar electronic media from these activities, profits from services such as individual courses, training, data processing and development and product promotion provided over these media, and profits earned by developers of applications for mobile devices such as smartphones or tablets only through electronic application sharing and sales platforms are taxed as commercial profit, and Repeated Article 20/B of Law No. 193 exempts profits from these activities from income tax subject to certain conditions.
Under these provisions and explanations, since your activity of writing games for the website named … is not aimed at mobile devices such as smartphones or tablets and the income is not earned through electronic application sharing and sales platforms, you cannot benefit from that exemption for these profits.
In this framework, payments made to you by that website for the games you upload to it must be treated as "commercial profit" under Article 37 of the Income Tax Law and the profits you earn taxed under the commercial profit provisions.
For your information.
(*) This ruling has been issued under Article 413 of Tax Procedure Law No. 213.
(**) This ruling is invalid if incorrect information has been provided on this matter while it is under tax examination, judicial review or settlement.
(***) If you act in accordance with this ruling issued at your request and tax has to be assessed as a result, no tax penalty will be imposed on you and no late payment interest will be calculated on the tax assessed.
Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.