The question was whether the guarantee, guarantee undertaking declarations and legal opinion to be submitted to the Capital Markets Board to secure obligations arising from warrants to be issued in Turkey by a foreign-resident issuer are exempt from stamp duty.
The Administration's view:
- The "Guarantee" and "Guarantee Undertaking Declaration" papers guaranteeing the warrant obligations up to a set amount are exempt from stamp duty under paragraph IV-36 of Table (2) of the Stamp Duty Law.
- The legal opinion addressed to the Capital Markets Board is not among the papers in Table (1) and is outside the scope of stamp duty.
The ruling is relevant to foreign institutions issuing capital market instruments in Turkey and their guarantors.
Full text
Subject: Whether the guarantee, guarantee undertaking declaration and legal opinion given for securities issued by foreign financial institutions are exempt from stamp duty
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.
Upon review of your ruling request form and its annexes referred to above, it is understood that you request an opinion on whether the guarantee, the guarantee undertaking declarations (2 copies) and the legal opinion issued by … for submission to the Capital Markets Board in order to secure the obligations arising from warrants (securities/capital market instruments) to be issued in Turkey, under Capital Markets Law No. 6362 and Communiqué VII-128.3 on Warrants and Investment Institution Certificates, by the foreign-resident … whose attorney you are, are exempt from stamp duty under paragraph (36) of the section titled "IV-Papers relating to commercial and civil matters" of Table (2) annexed to Stamp Duty Law No. 488.
Article 1 of Stamp Duty Law No. 488 provides that the papers listed in Table (1) annexed to the Law are subject to stamp duty; that the term papers means documents drawn up by being written and signed or by affixing a mark replacing a signature, which may be submitted to prove or show any matter, as well as documents created on magnetic media as electronic data using an electronic signature; and that papers drawn up in foreign countries and in foreign embassies and consulates in Turkey are subject to tax if submitted to official offices in Turkey, transferred or endorsed, or if their provisions are benefited from in any way. Article 2 provides that letters and annotations having the nature of, or replacing, taxable papers, and letters and annotations concerning the renewal, extension, amendment, transfer or termination of the provisions of such papers, are also subject to stamp duty. Article 3 provides that the taxpayers of stamp duty are those who sign the papers, and that the tax on papers drawn up in foreign countries and in foreign embassies and consulates in Turkey is paid by those who submit them to official offices in Turkey, transfer or endorse them, or benefit from their provisions in any way. Article 4 provides that the nature of a paper is considered to determine the tax to which it is subject, and the tax is found accordingly in the table; in determining the nature of papers, those whose form is specified by law are judged by their names in the law, and others by the provisions and meaning contained in their text. Article 9 provides that the papers listed in Table (2) annexed to the Law are exempt from stamp duty.
Paragraph A/1 of the section titled "I. Papers relating to contracts" of Table (1) annexed to the said Law provides that contracts, undertakings and assignments containing a specific amount of money, and paragraph A/3 that surety, guarantee and pledge instruments, are subject to proportional stamp duty. Paragraph 36 of the section titled "IV-Papers relating to commercial and civil matters" of Table (2) provides that receipts and papers issued in connection with the issuance of capital market instruments and the collateral subject to such issuance, including those to which the collateral agent is a party under Article 31/B of Capital Markets Law No. 6362, and receipts and papers issued in connection with housing finance transactions of housing finance institutions and the issuance of securities by these institutions representing mortgage-backed capital market instruments, asset-backed securities and asset finance funds and the collateral subject to such issuance, are exempt from stamp duty.
Among the annexes to your ruling request form,
- from the review of the paper titled "Guarantee" dated … and signed by …, it is stated in its "Preamble" section that … has prepared a prospectus (consisting of a capital market instrument note, issuer information document and summary) under which …, among others, may from time to time issue in Turkey all kinds of unsecured investment institution warrants, certificates and notes governed by Turkish law, including but not limited to investment institution warrants, certificates and notes relating to shares, indices, commodities and/or currencies (securities); that … will not grant any security interest in favour of the relevant Securityholders in respect of the securities; and that … wishes to guarantee the obligations of … under the Securities issued under the prospectus in the manner and to the extent set out in the prospectus. Article 1, titled "Guarantee", states that, subject to the following articles, … unconditionally and irrevocably guarantees to each warrant holder that, if … for any reason fails to pay any amount payable by it or to perform any other obligation relating to any warrant on the date such payment or performance is due, … will pay that amount in the currency in which payment is due under the prospectus and in immediately available funds, or, as the case may be, perform or procure the performance of the relevant obligation on the due date up to … Euro (Guaranteed Amount); and that if … fails to perform such an obligation when due, … undertakes, after a demand is made on … under Article 10 of the guarantee, to make or procure such payment or perform or procure the performance of such obligations up to the guaranteed amount as if … were the principal obligor. Article 9, titled "Term of the Guarantee", states that this guarantee is given by … in respect of all securities issued during a period of thirteen (13) months from the date the prospectus is approved by the Capital Markets Board of Turkey and, for the avoidance of doubt, covers, up to the guaranteed amount, all amounts payable by … in respect of such securities until their maturity date and/or in connection with their redemption;
- from the review of the paper titled "Guarantee Undertaking Declaration" dated … and addressed to the Capital Markets Board, it is stated that … undertakes to perform, up to … Euro being the guaranteed amount under the guarantee dated …, all obligations arising and to arise from the investment institution warrants issued in Turkey by …, and that the guarantor and the issuer are jointly and severally liable for the performance of those obligations.
In this context, the papers titled "Guarantee" and "Guarantee Undertaking Declaration", understood to have been issued for the guarantee by … of up to … Euro of the obligations arising and to arise from the warrants issued in Turkey by …, must be exempted from stamp duty under paragraph (36) of the section titled "IV-Papers relating to commercial and civil matters" of Table (2) annexed to Law No. 488.
On the other hand, the paper relating to the legal opinion annexed to the application, understood to be addressed to the Capital Markets Board, does not fall within the scope of stamp duty since it is not among the papers listed in Table (1) annexed to Law No. 488.
Kindly be informed.
Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.