A company buying goods from a German manufacturer and selling them to a customer in Germany without bringing them to Turkey, with 19% German VAT arising on purchase and sale, asked how to record the foreign VAT, how to invoice, and whether the document requested in Germany is problematic under the TPL.
The Administration's view:
- The fully liable company's income from this sale is included in the corporate tax base.
- As delivery does not take place in Turkey, the transaction is outside the scope of VAT.
- Since the invoice to the buyer will not be annexed to a customs declaration, it is issued as an e-archive invoice with type "SATIŞ", on the actual sale price (including German VAT passed on), within seven days of delivery.
- Provided the required information is present, additional information not impairing the invoice's nature may be included.
- VAT incurred abroad and shown on the invoice under the foreign legislation is included in the cost of the goods.
The ruling is relevant to Turkish companies trading goods entirely abroad.
Full text
Subject: Taxation of goods bought abroad and sold to a Germany-resident company without being imported into Turkey
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.
In your ruling request form referred to above, stating that your Company wishes to sell to a customer in Germany shampoos purchased from a Germany-resident firm, that the customer will collect them from the German manufacturer's factory, and that because delivery takes place in Germany, 19% VAT arises for you under German tax legislation on both the purchase and the sale, our Administration's opinion is requested on:
- how the VAT incurred will be recorded in your books if 19% VAT is calculated on the price of the products bought from the German manufacturer and invoiced to you,
- if the VAT incurred on purchase is passed on to the customer in Germany, how VAT should be shown on the e-invoice issued, whether this sale is considered transit trade, and whether, since you cannot issue a foreign invoice with VAT, the VAT incurred should be shown as sales revenue,
- given that VAT liability arises for you under German tax legislation and, for taxation, your Company is asked for a document on company letterhead showing the tax identification number you will obtain in Germany, the sale price and the VAT in separate columns, whether issuing this document under your Company's liability in Germany is an erroneous transaction under the Tax Procedure Law.
IN TERMS OF CORPORATE TAX:
Article 3 of the Corporate Tax Law provides that corporations listed in Article 1 whose legal or business centre is in Turkey are fully liable and taxed on all their income earned in and outside Turkey; and Article 6 provides that corporate tax is calculated on the net corporate income earned in an accounting period and that the provisions of the Income Tax Law on commercial income apply in determining it.
Furthermore, the first paragraph of Article 38 of the Income Tax Law, titled "Determination of commercial income on the balance sheet basis", provides that commercial income on the balance sheet basis is the positive difference between the values of equity at the end and beginning of the accounting period, that values added to the business by the owner(s) during the period are deducted from this difference, and that values withdrawn are added.
Under these provisions, the income your fully liable Company earns from selling goods purchased abroad to another company in Turkey or abroad must be included in the corporate tax base.
IN TERMS OF VAT:
VAT Law No. 3065 provides:
- in Article 1/1, that deliveries and services performed in Turkey within commercial, industrial, agricultural and professional activities, and in Article 1/2, that all imports of goods and services, are subject to VAT,
- in Article 6/a, that goods being in Turkey at the time of delivery means the transaction is performed in Turkey.
Accordingly, the sale by your Company of goods purchased in Germany to a company resident in Germany without bringing them to Turkey is outside the scope of VAT since the delivery does not take place in Turkey.
IN TERMS OF THE TAX PROCEDURE LAW:
Tax Procedure Law No. 213 provides (in summary of the provisions quoted in the Turkish text): in Article 3/B that the actual nature of the taxable event and related transactions is essential in taxation; in Article 215/2-a that records and documents use the Turkish currency, documents may also be issued in foreign currency provided the TL equivalent is shown, but the TL equivalent is not required on documents issued to customers abroad; in Article 227 that records relating to transactions with third parties must be documented and that documents, including electronic documents, lacking the required information are deemed not issued; in Article 229 the definition of an invoice; in Article 230 the minimum information on an invoice; in Article 231/1-5 that the invoice is issued within at most seven days of delivery or service; in Article 232 who must issue and receive invoices; in Repeated Articles 242 and 257 the Ministry's authority over electronic books, records and documents; in Article 258 the definition of valuation; in Article 262 the elements of cost; and in Article 274 that goods are valued at cost.
Furthermore, the section titled "Transactions Relating to Amounts Paid for Work and Services Performed by Taxpayers Operating Abroad" of Tax Procedure Law General Communiqué Serial No. 253 states that income or corporate taxpayers paying for work or services performed by persons or institutions resident abroad may record valid documents received from them as expenses in their books; that taxpayers receiving documents from foreign persons or companies will convert the amounts into Turkish Lira at the CBRT foreign exchange buying rate on the document date when recording them as expenses; and that, if deemed necessary by the examiner, taxpayers must have these documents translated. Therefore, in applying Article 227, documents issued by foreign-resident companies are accepted as proof/documentation if they are valid under the relevant country's legislation.
In this context, for amounts incurred on purchases from abroad to be recorded as expense or cost elements according to their nature, they must in principle be documented with the documents in Articles 229 et seq. of the Law; otherwise, they can be taken into account as expense or cost only if documented with a document obtained from abroad that is valid under the relevant country's tax legislation.
Tax Procedure Law General Communiqué Serial No. 509 regulates e-documents, and section "IV.1.4. Obligation to Switch to e-Invoice" explains in detail the taxpayers obliged to switch to e-invoicing.
Section "IV.2.4.1. Obligation of e-Invoice Users to Switch to e-Archive Invoice" of that Communiqué states that taxpayers obliged to use e-invoice, or who switched voluntarily, must also switch to e-archive invoice within the specified periods and, apart from the exceptions in sections "V.7." and "VIII.", issue their invoices as e-invoices or e-archive invoices; thus emphasizing that taxpayers switching to e-invoice must also switch to e-archive.
Section "IV.1.7.1. Obligation to Use e-Invoice in Export Transactions" of the Communiqué states that e-invoice users issuing invoices for exports of goods under Article 11 of VAT Law No. 3065 (including suitcase trade sales with special invoices to non-residents) and exports of goods carried by passengers must issue them as e-invoices from 1/7/2017 (1/7/2020 for suitcase trade sales), apart from the exceptions in sections "V.7." and "VIII.".
The section "3- EXPORT INVOICE" of the "e-Invoice Application Customs Procedures Guide" published at www.ebelge.gib.gov.tr states that the obligation to issue export invoices as e-invoices applies only to goods export invoices annexed to the Customs Declaration; export invoices annexed to other documents (Free Zone Transaction Form, transit trade form etc.) are not within e-invoice; for these, profile type IHRACAT and invoice type ISTISNA are selected, and in other cases not subject to a customs declaration, profile type TEMELFATURA/TICARIFATURA and invoice type ISTISNA are selected with the relevant exemption code.
An examination of the system regarding your Company shows that your e-invoice account was closed on … and your e-archive invoice account on …, and that you were a registered e-invoice and e-archive invoice user before these dates.
Accordingly:
1- Since the invoice your Company will issue to the buyer in Germany will not be annexed to a Customs Declaration and the delivery is outside the scope of VAT, it must be issued as an "e-Archive Invoice" with the "SATIŞ (sale) invoice type".
2- For your purchases from abroad, the foreign seller must issue an invoice (or a document valid under the relevant country's tax legislation) in your name; for your Company's sales, your Company must issue an invoice in the buyer's name on the actual sale price (including the VAT paid in Germany stated to be passed on to the buyer) within seven days of delivery.
3- Article 230 of the Law lists the minimum information required on an invoice and contains no provision prohibiting other information. Therefore, provided the required information is included, additional information can be shown on the invoice in a way that does not impair its essential nature or prevent it from being read.
4- VAT incurred on goods purchased abroad from foreign-resident businesses, calculated under the relevant country's legislation and shown on invoices (or documents valid under that country's tax legislation) issued in your name by these businesses, must be taken into account in determining the cost of the goods.
5- Explanations on the uniform chart of accounts are given in Accounting System General Communiqué Serial No. 1 and subsequent communiqués, and the accounting entries for your commercial transactions must be made in the books and records required under the Tax Procedure Law according to the explanations in these Communiqués.
Kindly be informed.
(*) This ruling has been issued under Article 413 of Tax Procedure Law No. 213.
(**) This ruling is invalid if incorrect information has been provided on this matter while it is under tax examination, judicial review or settlement.
(***) If you act in accordance with this ruling issued at your request and tax has to be assessed as a result, no tax penalty will be imposed on you and no late payment interest will be calculated on the tax assessed.
Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.